Some businesses reach a point where they ask whether they really need two separate people running finance and operations. Merging the Chief Financial Officer and Chief Operating Officer into a single dual role can look like an elegant solution — one leader, one integrated view of the numbers and the operations, one salary instead of two. For the right business at the right stage it can work well. For the wrong one it concentrates too much in a single person and creates risk. This guide sets out both sides honestly, so you can judge whether a combined CFO-COO seat fits your business rather than simply whether it sounds efficient. Where a site or operation needs leadership quickly, an interim Operations Director can step in.
It covers why companies combine the roles, the risks that come with doing so, the businesses where the structure tends to work, the extra considerations for FCA- and PRA-regulated firms, and how to recruit for a role that asks one person to be credible in two different disciplines.
Why Businesses Combine the Two Roles
The logic is real, not just cost-saving. Finance and operations are deeply intertwined — operational decisions have financial consequences and financial constraints shape what operations can do. A single leader across both can bring genuine advantages. Smaller businesses often appoint a part-time CFO for one or two days a week.
A single, integrated view of the business
When one person owns both finance and operations, financial strategy and operational execution are developed together rather than negotiated across a functional boundary. Investment decisions reflect operational reality; operational plans are grounded in what the numbers will bear. That coherence is the strongest argument for the combined role.
In practice this shows up in the budget cycle. Instead of finance setting a cost envelope and operations arguing for more, one leader builds the operating plan and the financial plan at the same desk. Capacity, pricing, working capital and headcount are looked at as one problem, which tends to produce plans the business can actually deliver.
Faster decisions
Merging the roles removes a hand-off. Where a separate CFO and COO would need to align before a major decision, a single leader can move faster — useful in a fast-moving or resource-constrained business where speed matters more than depth of specialist coverage.
Cost and headcount efficiency
One senior salary instead of two is a material saving, particularly for a scaling business that needs senior capability across both areas but cannot yet justify two full C-suite hires. For many mid-market and growth companies this is the practical trigger for considering the combined role at all. It is worth remembering, though, that a genuinely dual-capable executive will usually command more than a specialist in either seat, so the saving is real but smaller than a simple “one salary instead of two” suggests.
A single point of accountability
A combined CFO-COO gives the CEO and board one person accountable for both the financial health and the operational delivery of the business, which can simplify reporting lines and give external stakeholders a clear, streamlined leadership picture. Lenders and investors in particular often value having one senior contact who can answer questions on trading, cash and delivery without referring them elsewhere.
The Risks You Have to Weigh
These benefits are real, but so are the risks — and the original enthusiasm for “combining for efficiency” often glosses over them. A responsible view of the dual role has to take them seriously.
The span is enormous
The CFO role alone — reporting, controls, funding, investor relations, compliance — is a full-time job at any business of scale. So is the COO role — operations, delivery, process, often people. Asking one person to do both well is a genuine stretch, and beyond a certain size it simply isn’t realistic. The combined role tends to work at earlier stages and break down as complexity grows. Our guide to how the CEO, CFO and COO roles divide sets out how much each seat carries on its own.
Key-person risk
Concentrating finance and operations in one individual creates a single point of failure. If that person leaves, is ill, or underperforms, the business loses leadership across two critical functions at once rather than one. The more the business depends on the role, the more acute this risk becomes. A combined role therefore needs a stronger second line than usual — a capable financial controller and an operations lead who could each hold the fort for a period.
Diluted specialist depth
Finance and operations reward different expertise. A brilliant CFO is not automatically a strong operator, and vice versa. A dual appointment often means accepting someone who is strong in one domain and merely competent in the other — acceptable in some businesses, a serious weakness in others, particularly regulated firms where financial oversight cannot be a part-time concern.
Burnout and oversight gaps
Overloading a single executive with two demanding remits risks burnout and the kind of oversight gaps that appear when no one has the bandwidth to go deep. What looks efficient on an org chart can quietly degrade the quality of both functions.
Hiring a CFO, COO or a combined role?
Exec Capital helps boards decide whether to split or combine finance and operations leadership, then searches for permanent, interim or fractional candidates who fit that structure.
Controls, Challenge and Segregation of Duties
One risk deserves its own section because it is the one most often missed. In a conventional structure the CFO acts as a check on operations: finance questions spend, tests the business case for new capacity, reconciles what operations reports against what the ledger shows, and owns the controls that stop money leaving the business without proper authority. When the same person runs operations, that challenge has to come from somewhere else.
None of this makes the combined role unworkable, but it does mean the board should design the controls deliberately rather than assume they still operate. Practical safeguards include:
- Clear authority limits. Approval thresholds for operational spend that require a second signature — usually the CEO — above a set level, even where the CFO-COO is the budget holder.
- A strong financial controller. Someone below the dual leader who owns the month-end close, reconciliations and payment controls, with a direct line to the audit committee or board if something looks wrong.
- Independent review. Use of external auditors, an internal audit provider or a non-executive with finance experience to test the areas where the combined leader is effectively reviewing their own work.
- Separate reporting on performance and cash. Board packs that present operational KPIs and financial results in a way the board can reconcile, rather than one narrative written by one person.
For companies applying the UK Corporate Governance Code, the board is expected to monitor the company’s risk management and internal control framework and report on the effectiveness of material controls. A combined finance-and-operations executive does not prevent that, but the board will need to be able to explain how independent challenge is maintained when the person who runs the operations also designs the controls over them.
When the Combined Role Tends to Fit
In our experience the dual CFO-COO works best in specific circumstances: earlier-stage or mid-market businesses where neither function yet justifies a dedicated full-time C-suite hire; businesses with relatively contained operational complexity; and situations where an exceptional individual genuinely has depth in both areas rather than one. It fits less well in larger, more complex or regulated organisations, where the depth and the key-person risk both argue for separate leaders. Where a business needs the capability but not yet the two full-time seats, a fractional COO or fractional CFO in one of the functions is often a better route than overloading a single permanent hire.
Some patterns we see where the structure tends to work:
- Service businesses with light physical operations. Where “operations” is mainly about people, utilisation, pricing and systems, a commercially minded finance leader can often run it well.
- Private equity-backed businesses in a defined value-creation plan. Where the plan is about margin, cash and efficiency, one leader driving both the numbers and the operating changes can make sense for the hold period.
- Founder-led businesses moving to their first senior team. A dual leader can bring structure to both areas at once before the business is ready to split them.
- Businesses with a strong CEO who is close to operations. Where the CEO already carries much of the operational load, the “COO” half of the role is lighter and more manageable.
It tends to struggle in manufacturing, logistics and other asset-heavy businesses with complex supply chains, in multi-site or international groups, and in any business going through a funding round, refinancing or sale process where the finance workload spikes for months at a time.
Combining the Roles in an FCA- or PRA-Regulated Firm
Regulated financial services firms face an extra layer of questions, because under the Senior Managers and Certification Regime both roles can be regulatory functions in their own right. The Chief Finance function is SMF2 and the Chief Operations function is SMF24. For firms regulated by the PRA, the Bank of England’s supervisory statement on strengthening individual accountability (SS28/15) describes SMF24 as responsibility for the internal operations and technology of the firm, and treats SMF2 as mandatory for banks, building societies and designated investment firms. For FCA solo-regulated firms, both functions sit within the enhanced tier of the regime; core firms do not have them as separate functions, and a finance-and-operations director on the board would more usually be approved as an executive director.
There is no general rule against one person holding both SMF2 and SMF24. The regulators accept that one individual can perform more than one senior management function, and the FCA’s Senior Managers Regime guidance makes clear that where one person is to hold two functions, approval is sought for both. The PRA’s statement does, however, say it may refuse a combination where the functions cannot be performed effectively together, and the rules set out specific restrictions elsewhere — for example, the Chair must not also perform the Chief Executive function, the Chief Risk function must be independent with distinct responsibility for risk management, and internal audit must be separate and independent from the other functions of the firm.
That independence point is where combined CFO-COO roles in regulated firms most often need care. The PRA notes that responsibility for financial and regulatory reporting is often shared between the Chief Finance and Chief Risk functions. If a dual CFO-COO also drifts into owning risk oversight, the firm can end up with one person running operations, reporting on them and assessing the risks they create. Firms considering the combination should be able to show the regulator, in the Statement of Responsibilities and the Management Responsibilities Map, that risk and audit challenge sits with someone else, and that the individual has the time and competence to discharge both functions. Our guide on whether one person can hold more than one SMF covers the approval side in more detail.
The regime itself has been changing. The FCA’s policy statement PS26/6 on the SM&CR review took effect for most measures in April 2026. Among other changes, it gives firms 12 weeks to submit an SMF application when covering an unexpected or temporary vacancy, rather than requiring approval within that period, and raises the thresholds for enhanced firms. A second phase of reform has been signalled, so any firm planning a dual appointment should check the current rules at the point of application rather than relying on older guidance.
How to Hire for a Dual CFO-COO Role
If you decide the combined role fits, hiring for it is harder than hiring for either role alone, because the candidate pool of people genuinely strong across both finance and operations is small. The brief has to be explicit about where the emphasis lies — is this a finance leader who will also run operations, or an operator who will also own the numbers? — because very few candidates are truly balanced, and pretending otherwise leads to a poor hire. Assessment needs to test both domains properly rather than taking a strong CFO track record as evidence of operational capability. This is precisely the kind of appointment where a structured executive search process earns its place: the market has to be mapped for a rare profile, and the shortlist assessed against a mandate that two ordinary role specifications would miss.
Useful questions to build into the process include:
- Evidence of operational ownership. Has the candidate actually run a team, a site, a delivery function or a supply chain, or have they only reported on one? Ask for specific changes they led and what happened to cost, quality and service as a result.
- Depth on the finance side. Can they run a statutory audit, a refinancing and a forecast the board will trust? An operator who has picked up finance informally may be exposed when the business needs a funding round or a lender covenant reset.
- How they build a team beneath them. A dual leader succeeds through the people below them. Ask how they have structured a finance team and an operations team, and who they would hire first.
- How they handle being their own check. Ask directly how they would maintain challenge and controls over operations they also run. Strong candidates will have a clear answer; weaker ones will not have thought about it.
Qualified accountants who have moved into commercial or operational leadership are a common source of candidates, as are operations directors with a finance background in manufacturing or services. Many of the strongest dual leaders come from private equity-backed businesses, where finance and operational improvement are closely tied. Our CFO search team maps both pools when a client is open to either profile.
It is also worth being honest at the outset about whether the combined role is a permanent structure or a stage the business will grow out of. Many companies use a dual CFO-COO through a particular phase and later split the roles as they scale — a transition worth planning for rather than stumbling into, and one our guide on how the CFO and COO roles differ may help you think through.
A Simple Way to Decide
If you are weighing the combined role, a short set of questions cuts through most of the theory. How complex are your operations, really — could one person credibly hold both remits at your current scale? Is your business regulated, where financial oversight cannot be diluted? Do you actually have access to a candidate with genuine depth in both finance and operations, or are you hoping one exists? And is this a permanent structure or a bridge until you can afford two hires? If your operations are contained, you are not heavily regulated, you have a genuinely dual-capable candidate, and you are clear-eyed about the key-person risk, the combined role is worth pursuing. If two or more of those answers give you pause, you are usually better splitting the roles — or filling one on a fractional basis until you can justify both.
There is also a middle route that many businesses overlook: appoint a permanent leader for the function that matters most right now, and bring in a fractional or interim executive for the other. A growth business preparing for investment might hire a permanent CFO and use a part-time COO to tighten delivery; a business with an operational problem might do the reverse. This gives specialist depth in both areas without two full-time senior salaries, and keeps the option of a permanent second hire open.
How the Structure Tends to Evolve
It helps to see the dual CFO-COO not as a permanent fixture but as a structure that suits a particular phase. Early on, a single strong leader across finance and operations gives a growing business coherence and saves a salary it cannot yet spare. As the business scales, the two remits each deepen — funding rounds, investor relations and controls on the finance side; larger teams, more complex delivery and process on the operations side — until the load genuinely exceeds one person. The businesses that handle this best plan the split in advance: they know roughly at what scale or complexity they will separate the roles, and they hire a dual leader who can either grow into one of the two seats or hand over cleanly. Treating the combined role as a deliberate stage, rather than a permanent answer, avoids the trap of clinging to it past the point where it serves the business.
Signs that the time to split has arrived include month-end slipping because the leader is pulled into operational issues, operational projects stalling during audit or budget season, the board asking for more depth on either side, or a transaction on the horizon. When that happens, the cleanest approach is usually to agree with the incumbent which seat they will keep, then recruit for the other with a clear handover period.
Frequently asked questions
Can one person be both CFO and COO?
Yes. There is no legal bar in an unregulated company, and many mid-market businesses run this way. The question is whether the business is small and simple enough for one person to do both properly, and whether controls are in place to provide the challenge a separate CFO would normally give.
Can the same person hold SMF2 and SMF24?
The regulators allow one individual to hold more than one senior management function, and approval is sought for each. The PRA can refuse a combination that cannot be performed effectively, and the firm must keep risk and internal audit functions independent. Firms should take regulatory advice on their own circumstances before applying.
What should the job title be?
Common titles include CFO and COO, Chief Financial and Operating Officer, and Finance and Operations Director in smaller businesses. The title matters less than a clear statement of responsibilities and of which half of the role carries more weight.
Is a combined role cheaper than two hires?
Usually, but by less than you might expect. Candidates with real depth in both disciplines are scarce and priced accordingly. Combining one permanent leader with a fractional executive in the other function can sometimes deliver more depth for a similar cost.
When should we split the roles again?
When the workload on either side consistently crowds out the other, when the board wants more specialist depth, or ahead of a fundraising, refinancing or sale. Planning the split early makes the transition smoother for the incumbent and for the business.
Deciding whether to split or combine finance and operations?
We advise founders and boards on senior finance and operations structure, and run the search when you know what you need — including the rare dual CFO-COO appointment.
Related Finance and Operations Leadership Services
Whether you split the roles or combine them, the right structure depends on your stage and complexity. Exec Capital places finance and operations leaders on permanent, interim and fractional terms. Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.
PRACTICE AREA
CFO Search
Permanent, fractional and interim Chief Financial Officers for growing and PE-backed businesses.
PRACTICE AREA
COO Search
Chief Operating Officers to run delivery, process and operational scale.
PRACTICE AREA
Flexible Leadership
Senior finance and operations capability without a second full-time appointment.
PRACTICE AREA
Regulated Firms
Finance and operations leaders for FCA- and PRA-regulated firms, including SMF2 and SMF24 roles.
Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.
About the author
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name, with more than 25 years’ experience operating at C-suite level. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what senior leadership hires actually require. View Adrian’s ICAEW profile.
Related posts:
Recruiting a Chief Financial Officer (CFO) or Finance Director (FD) who specialises in mergers and a...
Recruiting a CEO for an FCA-Authorised Firm: What Makes the Brief Different
How to Find an Outsourced CFO Provider: Key Factors to Consider
Salary Guide for Chief Financial Officers: Navigating Bonuses and Incentives
How Fractional CFOs Drive Growth in High-Growth Startups
Leading the Financial Frontline: Unraveling London CFO Recruitment
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant and holds an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name with over 25 years’ experience operating at C-suite level, Adrian brings direct executive experience to senior search. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies, and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what leadership hires actually require.