Insurance Recruitment

Senior insurance search for insurers, Lloyd's managing agents, MGAs and brokers – CEO, CUO (SMF23), Chief Actuary and fractional SMF16. Tell us your hire.

  • Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW
  • Permanent, interim and fractional C-suite hires
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Agreeing terms after a review

Senior Search for UK Insurance — Lloyd’s, Composites, MGAs, Reinsurance and Broking

Exec Capital provides senior insurance recruitment for UK insurance firms across the four market segments — Lloyd’s of London market participants, composite insurers, specialist insurers and managing general agents (MGAs), reinsurers — and the UK insurance broking sector. The UK insurance market is one of the largest in the world by premium volume — a senior search market shaped by three structural dimensions that warrant explicit practitioner treatment: PRA prudential accountability under Solvency UK (the UK’s restated Solvency II regime), the IFRS 17 senior team transition (current, not historical), and senior team accountability under SMCR with insurance-specific Senior Management Functions, including SMF20 Chief Actuary and SMF23 Chief Underwriting Officer.

Our practice covers UK senior insurance appointments across Lloyd’s of London market participants (Lloyd’s syndicates, managing agents, Lloyd’s brokers), UK composite insurers (Aviva — which now includes Direct Line following its acquisition completed on 1 July 2025 — RSA, Admiral, LV=, NFU Mutual, Allianz UK, AXA UK, Zurich UK), specialist insurers and MGAs (Hiscox, Beazley, Markel International, Tokio Marine HCC, Kiln, Talbot, Hardy), reinsurers (Munich Re UK, Swiss Re UK, Hannover Re UK, SCOR UK), and the UK insurance broking sector (Aon, Marsh, WTW, Howden, Gallagher, Lockton, McGill). Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate. For senior CFO appointments at PRA-authorised insurance firms — including Solvency UK and IFRS 17 dimensions — see our sister firm FD Capital.

This page is the hub for our insurance practice. It sets out how we run senior insurance searches, which senior manager functions apply to which kind of firm, when a permanent, interim or fractional appointment fits better, and how the fractional compliance route works for brokers and MGAs that need an approved SMF16 without a full-time salary. If you already know the role, our dedicated pages for insurance underwriter recruitment, the SMF23 Chief Underwriting Officer and the SMF20 Chief Actuary go into more depth.

For approved roles at brokers and insurers, SMF Capital runs SMF recruitment for insurance firms.

Short answer

Insurance recruitment at senior level means finding leaders who fit a specific market segment (Lloyd’s, composite, MGA, reinsurance or broking) and who can be approved for the relevant senior manager function by the PRA or FCA. Exec Capital runs permanent, interim and fractional searches for insurers, managing agents, MGAs and brokers, from CEO and Chief Underwriting Officer to a fractional SMF16 compliance lead for a small broker.

Tell us about your hire

From the desk

Most of our insurance work is with brokers, MGAs and new entrants

Large insurers usually hire senior people through their own teams. The insurance work that comes to the group is mostly from brokers, managing general agents and new entrants, including a US insurtech setting up UK regulated roles for its carrier’s UK branch.

For new entrants the timetable is set as much by regulatory approval as by the search itself. We map which roles need FCA or PRA approval at the start and run those through our sister firm SMF Capital, so the business knows when each person can actually begin.

Adrian Lawrence FCA, Founder, Exec Capital

How a senior insurance search works

Every insurance mandate follows the same six stages. The detail inside each stage changes with the segment and the regulatory function, but the shape does not. We agree the timetable with you at briefing, and it reflects the role, the notice periods typical in your part of the market and whether a PRA or FCA approval sits at the end of the process.

Stage What happens
1. Brief We work through the segment (Lloyd’s, company market, composite, MGA, reinsurance, broking), the lines of business, the reporting line, the SMF the role will hold (if any), the Statement of Responsibilities, and the format: permanent, interim or fractional.
2. Search Direct approach to people doing the job now in comparable firms, plus our group network of finance, compliance and board-level candidates. We test segment credentials early rather than at final interview.
3. Shortlist A short, assessed shortlist with written notes on each candidate’s segment fit, regulatory history, approval readiness, notice period and package expectations.
4. Interviews We coordinate interviews with the executive team, board members and, where relevant, the parent group or Lloyd’s managing agent. We help you test Solvency UK, IFRS 17 and conduct knowledge at the right depth.
5. Offer Package negotiation, including deferral and buy-out of unvested awards where the candidate is leaving a listed insurer or a Lloyd’s business, plus regulatory references and criminal record checks.
6. Onboarding Support with the PRA or FCA approval application, the handover plan and the first 90 days. We stay in touch through the early months of the appointment.

The four market segments

UK insurance as a single industry term covers four distinct senior search markets. Strong searches start with segment clarity rather than treating the industry as undifferentiated.

The Lloyd’s of London market. Lloyd’s syndicates, managing agents, and Lloyd’s brokers operating in the Lloyd’s market — a specialty insurance market with distinctive culture, broker-led distribution, and line-by-line underwriting capacity. Senior search activity covers Active Underwriter and Class Underwriter appointments, Managing Agent CEO and senior management appointments, and senior broker appointments at Lloyd’s brokers. Strong candidates demonstrate Lloyd’s market credentials specifically — the Lloyd’s culture and the broker-led distribution model produce a senior candidate pool meaningfully distinct from non-Lloyd’s insurance. For underwriting roles at syndicates, see our page on Lloyd’s of London underwriters.

Composite insurers. UK composite insurance firms operating across personal lines, commercial lines, and (for life-and-pensions composites) life and protection lines — Aviva (including Direct Line, acquired in July 2025), RSA, Admiral, LV=, NFU Mutual, plus UK operations of international composites (Allianz UK, AXA UK, Zurich UK). Senior search activity covers CEO, COO, CFO, Chief Underwriting Officer, Chief Claims Officer, Chief Distribution Officer, and senior commercial appointments. Strong candidates bring composite-scale credentials with multi-product-line accountability and (where life is in scope) life and pensions actuarial credentials. Consolidation such as the Aviva–Direct Line combination also creates integration roles and moves experienced leaders into the wider market.

Specialist insurers and MGAs. Specialty insurance firms operating niche underwriting capability — Hiscox, Beazley, Markel International, Tokio Marine HCC, Kiln (Tokio Marine Kiln), Talbot (part of AIG), Hardy (CNA Hardy), RenaissanceRe UK — and the UK MGA sector providing delegated underwriting authority across specialty lines (cyber, professional indemnity, marine, energy, political risk, art and specie). Senior search activity covers Active Underwriter, Senior Underwriter, MGA CEO, and Head of Underwriting appointments.

Reinsurers. The UK reinsurance market — UK operations of global reinsurers (Munich Re UK, Swiss Re UK, Hannover Re UK, SCOR UK, RenaissanceRe), plus retrocessional capacity providers and the ILS (insurance-linked securities) market. Senior search activity covers Treaty and Facultative Underwriter appointments, Senior Reinsurance Broker appointments at retrocession brokers, and senior management at reinsurance subsidiaries. Our reinsurance recruitment page covers this segment in more detail.

Insurance broking and distribution. Alongside the four carrier segments sits the intermediary market: global and national brokers, specialist Lloyd’s brokers, consolidators, regional brokers and the MGAs that sit between broker and capacity. Brokers and most MGAs are regulated by the FCA alone rather than dual-regulated, so the senior manager functions that matter are FCA functions — typically SMF1 or SMF3 for the executive lead, SMF9 for the chair, and SMF16 for compliance oversight. That makes compliance leadership, often on a fractional basis, one of the most frequent senior hires in this part of the market (see the broker and MGA section below).

Senior insurance roles we recruit

CEO and senior management. CEO, COO, and senior management at insurance firms — accountability under SMF1 (CEO) and SMF24 (COO) at PRA/FCA dual-regulated firms. Strong candidates bring market-segment-specific track record, regulatory engagement credentials with the PRA and FCA, and sponsor-engagement credentials at PE-owned insurance firms or board engagement at listed insurance firms. Where a business needs leadership cover during a sale, integration or regulatory remediation, an interim CEO can hold the SMF1 role while the permanent search runs.

Chief Underwriting Officer. The Chief Underwriting Officer is a PRA senior management function — SMF23 — for firms carrying on general insurance business and for Lloyd’s managing agents. Appointment is subject to PRA approval and the role-holder is accountable for underwriting decisions on material insurance risks, underwriting authority delegation, portfolio management, and underwriting performance. Senior search dimensions include market-segment fit (Lloyd’s CUO versus composite CUO versus MGA CUO are different roles), portfolio management track record at scale, and PRA/FCA engagement credentials. See our dedicated Chief Underwriting Officer Recruitment service for fuller treatment.

Chief Risk Officer and Chief Actuary. Senior risk leadership at PRA-authorised insurance firms — the SMF4 Chief Risk function, with ORSA accountability, Pillar 2 governance dimensions under Solvency UK, and senior team interface with the actuarial function. Chief Actuary appointments (SMF20) where relevant — accountability for the actuarial function, technical provisions, the SCR calculation, and (since January 2023) IFRS 17 measurement model implementation and ongoing CSM management. For risk leadership outside insurance as well, see our Chief Risk Officer recruitment service.

Chief Financial Officer. CFO at insurance firms operates under Solvency UK reporting cadence (annual SFCR and RSR), the IFRS 17 financial reporting framework (since January 2023 — a substantial change from the IFRS 4 framework), and PRA prudential reporting. At insurers the CFO normally holds the PRA’s SMF2 Chief Finance function. For senior CFO appointments at PRA-authorised insurance firms specifically, see our sister firm FD Capital‘s insurance CFO service.

For qualified finance roles, Accountancy Capital covers financial controller recruitment for insurance intermediaries.

Chief Distribution Officer / Chief Commercial Officer. Senior commercial leadership covering distribution channels — broker channel (the dominant UK commercial lines distribution channel), direct channel, aggregator channel for personal lines, and (at MGAs) carrier relationship management. Strong candidates bring channel-specific track record at scale.

Senior underwriters and Active Underwriters. Senior underwriting professionals with line-of-business specialisation — property, casualty, marine, aviation, energy, financial lines (D&O, cyber, professional indemnity), specialty (political risk, art and specie), and (in life-and-pensions composites) life and protection underwriting. See our Insurance Underwriter Recruitment service for fuller treatment.

Senior insurance broking roles. Senior leadership at UK insurance broking firms — Aon, Marsh, WTW, Howden, Gallagher, Lockton, McGill plus specialist broking firms. Strong candidates bring client portfolio credentials, carrier relationships, and broking-specific commercial acumen distinct from carrier-side senior search dimensions.

Compliance, MLRO and board roles. Heads of compliance (SMF16), money laundering reporting officers (SMF17, where the firm is within the Money Laundering Regulations, which mainly affects life and investment-linked business), heads of internal audit (SMF5) and non-executive directors and committee chairs. For the board side, our guide to insurance company board appointments under SMCR explains which chair and committee roles carry an SMF at an insurer.

Hiring a senior leader for an insurer, MGA or broker?

Exec Capital runs permanent, interim and fractional insurance searches matched to your segment and to the PRA or FCA function the role will hold.

Contact Exec Capital →Tell us about your hire

Or call 0203 834 9616.

The UK insurance senior search dimensions

PRA Solvency UK senior team accountability. UK insurance senior leaders at PRA-authorised firms operate under Solvency UK — the PRA’s restatement of Solvency II in its own rulebook, which took effect on 31 December 2024 — covering Pillar 1 capital adequacy (SCR/MCR), Pillar 2 ORSA accountability, and Pillar 3 SFCR/RSR reporting. Senior team capability with these dimensions is decisive at brief stage. For PRA prudential framework context, see the PRA’s PS15/24 policy statement on the Solvency II review.

IFRS 17 senior team transition. UK insurers transitioned to IFRS 17 financial reporting from January 2023 — senior team implications include Chief Actuary capability with IFRS 17 measurement models (GMM, PAA, VFA), senior finance team understanding of CSM (Contractual Service Margin) recognition and ongoing release patterns, and senior board engagement with IFRS 17 results presentation. This is current senior search ground truth — strong senior candidates demonstrate IFRS 17 fluency, not just historical IFRS 4 credentials.

SMCR senior team accountability. Senior insurance appointments at PRA-authorised firms operate under SMCR with insurance-specific Senior Management Functions — including SMF23 Chief Underwriting Officer, SMF20 Chief Actuary, SMF4 Chief Risk Officer and SMF5 Head of Internal Audit — and senior team accountability around the approval application, fit-and-proper assessment, and ongoing personal regulatory accountability. The current list of insurance functions is set out in the PRA Rulebook’s Insurance – Senior Management Functions part. For fuller treatment, see our FCA-Regulated Firm Recruitment hub.

The London Market specificity. The Lloyd’s of London market and the London company market produce a distinctive senior candidate pool — specialty underwriting capability, broker-led distribution model, and London Market culture. Senior candidates from broader UK insurance backgrounds don’t automatically transfer into senior London Market roles without bridging credentials; equally, senior London Market candidates don’t automatically transfer into senior composite insurer roles. Strong searches address the segment direction explicitly.

Conduct and Consumer Duty. For any firm with retail customers — personal lines insurers, life companies, brokers and MGAs writing consumer business — the FCA’s Consumer Duty shapes what the board and senior team are expected to evidence. Candidates for CEO, distribution, claims and compliance roles should be able to talk about fair value assessments, product governance and outcomes monitoring in practical terms, not just in policy language. Our note on Consumer Duty and senior hiring decisions covers what this means for the brief.

Insurance senior manager functions at a glance

Which senior manager functions apply depends on the type of firm. Insurers and Lloyd’s managing agents are dual-regulated: the PRA approves its functions (such as SMF2, SMF4, SMF20 and SMF23) and the FCA approves its own (such as SMF16 and SMF17). Brokers and most MGAs are FCA solo-regulated and only need the FCA functions that apply to their category. The table below is a working summary for briefing purposes; the rulebooks are the authority, and our explainer on SMF20 and SMF23 goes further on the two insurance-specific roles.

Function Typical role Where it usually applies
SMF1 Chief Executive CEO, managing agent CEO Insurers and managing agents; FCA Core and Enhanced firms including brokers
SMF2 Chief Finance CFO, Finance Director Insurers and managing agents (at FCA Core firms a board CFO usually holds SMF3 instead)
SMF4 Chief Risk Chief Risk Officer Insurers and managing agents
SMF5 Head of Internal Audit Head of Internal Audit Insurers with an internal audit function
SMF20 Chief Actuary Chief Actuary, head of actuarial function Insurers and managing agents
SMF23 Chief Underwriting Officer CUO, Active Underwriter with firm-wide underwriting responsibility General insurers and Lloyd’s managing agents
SMF24 Chief Operations COO Insurers and managing agents; Enhanced FCA firms
SMF9 Chair Board chair Insurers, managing agents, FCA Core and Enhanced firms
SMF16 Compliance Oversight Head of Compliance, Chief Compliance Officer Insurers, managing agents, and FCA Core and Enhanced firms including most brokers and MGAs
SMF17 Money Laundering Reporting MLRO Firms within the Money Laundering Regulations — mainly life and investment-linked business, not most general insurance intermediaries

Committee chair functions (SMF10 to SMF12, and SMF14 for the senior independent director) apply at larger insurers and are covered in our board appointments guide. The regulators’ current consultations, discussed below, propose changing how some of these roles are approved, so check the position at the point of appointment.

Brokers and MGAs: fractional SMF16 and compliance oversight

The most common senior hire we see from smaller insurance businesses is not a CEO or a CUO. It is a compliance lead who can hold the SMF16 Compliance Oversight function. A regional broker, a start-up MGA or a newly authorised intermediary often needs an approved, experienced head of compliance — someone who can own the compliance monitoring plan, the Consumer Duty board report, complaints oversight, appointed representative oversight and the relationship with the FCA — but does not have the volume of work, or the budget, for a full-time senior hire.

A fractional chief compliance officer solves that. The individual works a set number of days a month, holds the SMF16 function once approved, reports to the board, and builds the compliance framework the firm needs, with a junior compliance officer or administrator doing the day-to-day work underneath. For firms that need a hands-on resource rather than board-level oversight, a fractional compliance officer may be the better fit. Where a head of compliance has left suddenly, or the firm is in remediation, an interim CCO provides full-time cover while a permanent appointment is made.

SMF17 is a separate question. General insurance intermediaries are mostly outside the Money Laundering Regulations, so many brokers and MGAs do not need an SMF17 at all. Firms that do life, protection-with-investment or pensions business usually do, and some firms choose to combine SMF16 and SMF17 in one person. Our guide to SMF16 versus SMF17 sets out when you need one, both or a combined role, and a fractional MLRO covers the money laundering side where it applies.

Two points matter when choosing a fractional SMF16. First, the person still needs FCA approval, and the FCA will look at whether they have the time and resources to do the job properly alongside their other commitments — so the number of days, the other roles they hold and the support underneath them all need to make sense on the application. Second, SMF16 and SMF17 remain pre-approved roles under the regulators’ latest SMCR proposals, so the approval step is not going away for compliance appointments.

When to hire permanent, interim, fractional or part-time

Insurance businesses use every format. The right answer depends on whether the need is permanent, how much time the role really takes, and whether a regulatory function has to be filled quickly.

Format Best for Typical insurance examples Where to start
Permanent Long-term leadership, succession, a role at the centre of the business plan CEO, CUO, Chief Actuary, CRO at an insurer or managing agent This page, plus the role pages for CUO and Chief Actuary
Interim Full-time cover for a vacancy, a transaction, integration or remediation Interim CFO through a year-end or sale; interim CRO or CCO during a regulatory review Interim CFO, Interim CRO, Interim CCO
Fractional Senior expertise for a few days a month, often holding an approved function Fractional SMF16 at a broker or MGA; fractional CFO at a growing MGA Fractional CCO, Fractional CFO, Fractional C-suite
Part-time A steady, ongoing need below full-time, employed rather than engaged Part-time finance lead or MLRO at a small intermediary Part-time CFO, Part-time MLRO

Many insurance clients combine formats: an interim holds a function while the permanent search runs, or a fractional compliance lead builds the framework before the firm is large enough for a full-time head of compliance. Our guide to choosing a permanent, interim or fractional compliance hire walks through that decision in more detail.

Regulatory approval and timing

Every senior manager appointment at an insurer, managing agent, broker or MGA has a regulatory step that sits outside the recruitment process but inside your timetable. Planning for it at the brief avoids the most common delay in insurance hiring: a candidate who has accepted, resigned and is ready to start, but cannot yet perform the function.

  • The statutory clock. Under section 61 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, the regulator must decide a complete application within three months. The clock stops while the regulator waits for information it has asked for.
  • Typical timing in practice. The FCA’s published median for senior manager approvals in 2025/26 was about 25 days. Dual-regulated appointments involving the PRA, and applications that raise questions, can take longer. Our guide to how long FCA SMF approval takes covers the practical drivers.
  • Temporary cover. Since the SMCR Phase 1 changes (FCA PS26/6) took effect on 24 April 2026, the FCA rule at SUP 10C.3A.6R gives a firm 12 weeks to submit an application when someone covers an SMF role on a temporary basis, with cover continuing until the application is decided. The October 2026 consultation proposes extending this to 18 weeks.
  • Proposed reforms. FCA CP26/37 and PRA CP14/26, published in October 2026, propose moving some senior manager functions to a notification basis. SMF1, SMF9, SMF16 and SMF17 stay pre-approved under the proposals. The FCA consultation closes on 22 January 2027, so nothing has changed yet for live appointments.
  • Checks and references. Regulatory references, criminal record checks and a fitness and propriety assessment are needed before the application goes in. Starting these at offer stage, not after the candidate joins, saves weeks.

If a function is already vacant, our urgent SMF appointment service focuses on getting an experienced, approvable person in place under the temporary cover rules while a longer-term solution is found. The FCA’s own SMCR pages set out the regime for solo-regulated firms.

What a senior insurance hire typically delivers in the first 90 days

The first three months look different for each role, but the strongest insurance appointments follow a similar pattern: understand the book, understand the regulator’s view, then set a plan the board can hold them to.

  • CEO or managing agent CEO. Meets the board, major capacity providers or parent, key brokers and the PRA and FCA supervisory contacts; reviews the business plan, the latest ORSA and any open regulatory actions; sets out priorities and any changes to the leadership team.
  • Chief Underwriting Officer. Reviews the portfolio by class, line size, rate adequacy and loss ratio; checks delegated authority arrangements and the controls around them; agrees underwriting guidelines and any remedial actions with the board.
  • Chief Actuary. Reviews reserving, technical provisions and the SCR methodology; checks the IFRS 17 models and the CSM roll-forward; builds the relationship with the external auditor and the finance team ahead of the next reporting cycle.
  • CFO. Takes ownership of the Solvency UK reporting calendar, the IFRS 17 close process and capital planning; reviews the finance team’s capacity and the quality of management information.
  • Fractional or interim SMF16 at a broker or MGA. Completes a compliance gap review; refreshes the compliance monitoring plan; checks Consumer Duty evidence, complaints handling, financial promotions and appointed representative oversight; and reports findings to the board with a costed action plan.

Our executive onboarding guide sets out how boards can structure the first 90 days so the new leader starts with the information and access they need.

Compensation and Package Structure

Insurance packages vary widely by segment, ownership and regulatory status, so we do not publish generic figures on this page. What we can say is how they are usually built. Listed insurers pay a base salary, an annual bonus with a deferred element and a long-term incentive plan, all within a remuneration policy approved by shareholders. PE-backed insurers, MGAs and brokers lean more on equity or growth shares, with an exit-linked payout. Lloyd’s businesses often add profit-related pay tied to underwriting results.

Regulation shapes variable pay too. Solvency UK carries remuneration requirements for insurers, including deferral of part of the variable pay for staff whose roles have a material impact on the firm’s risk profile. The banking bonus cap, which never applied to insurers, was removed for banks and investment firms on 31 October 2023, and the FCA and PRA remuneration reforms in PS25/15 and PS21/25 apply to banks and investment firms rather than insurers. For candidates leaving a listed insurer, buy-out of unvested deferred awards is often the largest negotiation point. For sourced benchmarks, see our SMF salary guide.

Engagement and fees

We agree the fee structure with you at briefing, once we understand the role, the format and how difficult the search is likely to be. The broad shape is:

  • Permanent senior appointments are normally run on a retained basis, which gives the search dedicated time and a structured process. Contingent terms can suit some less senior or more straightforward roles. Our guide to retained versus contingent executive search explains the difference.
  • Interim and fractional appointments are charged on a day-rate basis, and the day rate you pay includes our fee. You get one invoice and one point of contact for the engagement.
  • What is included: the briefing and role specification, the search and assessment, a written shortlist, interview coordination, referencing, offer negotiation, help with the regulatory approval paperwork and contact during the early months of the appointment.

Who we place for

Our insurance clients range from established carriers to businesses that have just been authorised. Typical clients include:

  • UK general insurers and the UK operations of international insurers and reinsurers.
  • Lloyd’s managing agents, syndicates and Lloyd’s brokers.
  • MGAs and coverholders, from start-ups seeking capacity to established specialty MGAs.
  • Insurance brokers, broker consolidators and appointed representative networks.
  • Life, protection and pensions businesses, and run-off and legacy specialists.
  • Private equity and other investors backing insurance and distribution businesses, who need leaders for portfolio companies.

Other ways to hire insurance leaders. This page is the overview. For a specific role or format, go straight to the sibling page: SMF23 Chief Underwriting Officer recruitment for the regulated underwriting lead, SMF20 Chief Actuary recruitment for the actuarial function, insurance underwriter recruitment for underwriting teams, and our sister practice SMF Capital’s SMF16 Head of Compliance recruitment page for permanent compliance leads. For board roles, our non-executive director recruitment team works alongside sister firm NED Capital.

Looking for an insurance role yourself? If you are a senior insurance professional, underwriter, actuary or compliance specialist interested in permanent, interim or fractional work, please register with us and keep an eye on our current opportunities. This page is written for hiring firms, but we are always glad to hear from experienced candidates.

Building leadership in a new broker or MGA

New brokers and managing general agents usually build their leadership in a set order, because the regulated roles come first. A recent enquiry to the group came from a general insurance broker start-up needing fractional compliance oversight (SMF16). The table shows the usual sequence.

Stage Typical leadership need Handled by
Applying for authorisation Compliance oversight and an MLRO, often fractional Our sister practice SMF Capital
Authorised and trading A managing director or CEO, and a finance lead, often fractional at first Exec Capital and FD Capital
Growing the book Commercial, underwriting or distribution leadership Exec Capital
Larger and more complex A board with independent non-executives Our sister practice NED Capital

Adrian says

Fractional suits most new brokers

A new broker rarely needs a full-time compliance officer, finance director and managing director on day one. Fractional appointments let it meet the regulator’s expectations without carrying full-time salaries before the income arrives.

Plan the order with the authorisation timetable in mind, and add full-time roles as the book grows.

Adrian Lawrence FCA, Founder, Exec Capital

See Lloyd’s underwriter search and fractional C-suite. Regulated appointments are handled by SMF Capital, finance roles by FD Capital and board roles by NED Capital.

Frequently asked questions

What does an insurance recruitment agency do at senior level?

At senior level it is executive search: defining the role with the board, approaching people already doing similar jobs, assessing them against the segment and the regulatory function, and managing the process through to offer and approval. Exec Capital covers insurers, managing agents, MGAs, reinsurers and brokers.

Which senior insurance roles need PRA or FCA approval?

At insurers and managing agents, the main approved roles include the CEO (SMF1), CFO (SMF2), CRO (SMF4), Head of Internal Audit (SMF5), Chief Actuary (SMF20), Chief Underwriting Officer (SMF23), COO (SMF24), the chair (SMF9) and the head of compliance (SMF16). At brokers and MGAs the FCA functions apply, usually SMF1 or SMF3, SMF9 and SMF16.

Is the Chief Underwriting Officer a senior manager function?

Yes. SMF23 Chief Underwriting Officer is a PRA function for firms carrying on general insurance business and for Lloyd’s managing agents, so the appointment needs PRA approval. See our SMF23 page for detail.

Can a small broker or MGA use a fractional SMF16?

Yes, and many do. A fractional head of compliance works a set number of days a month and holds SMF16 once approved. The FCA will want to see that they have enough time and support for the role. See our fractional CCO page.

Does a general insurance broker need an MLRO (SMF17)?

Usually not. Most general insurance intermediaries are outside the Money Laundering Regulations, so SMF17 does not apply. Firms doing life or investment-linked business usually do need one, and some combine SMF16 and SMF17 in one person.

What is Solvency UK and why does it matter for hiring?

Solvency UK is the PRA’s version of the Solvency II regime, restated in the PRA Rulebook from 31 December 2024. CFOs, CROs, Chief Actuaries and board members at insurers need working knowledge of its capital, ORSA and reporting requirements, so we test it at shortlist stage.

How long does a senior insurance appointment take?

It depends on the role, notice periods and the approval step. We agree the timetable with you at briefing. The FCA must decide a complete SMF application within three months, and its published median in 2025/26 was about 25 days.

What if our head of compliance or CUO leaves suddenly?

An interim can cover the role. Under the FCA’s temporary cover rule (SUP 10C.3A.6R), the firm has 12 weeks to submit an application for the person covering. We can place an interim or fractional lead while the permanent search runs.

How are your fees structured?

We agree the fee structure at briefing. Senior permanent searches are usually retained; interim and fractional appointments are on a day rate that includes our fee.

Do you recruit non-executive directors for insurers?

Yes. We place chairs, committee chairs and independent NEDs at insurers, managing agents and brokers, working with our sister firm NED Capital. Our insurance executive hiring guide also covers board-level hiring.

Further reading

For role-specific senior hiring guides at the insurance senior level, see our CFO hiring guide, CEO hiring guide, and the rest in our Knowledge Centre. For UK senior compensation including listed insurer LTIP structures, Lloyd’s market deferred remuneration, and PE-backed insurance compensation arrangements, see our Executive Compensation Guide and Equity and Incentives Guide. For an overview of the leading London market businesses, see our ranking of the London insurance and Lloyd’s market.

For senior CFO appointments at PRA-authorised insurance firms — including Solvency UK prudential reporting, IFRS 17 senior finance team capability, and ongoing PRA engagement dimensions — see our sister firm FD Capital‘s insurance CFO service. For senior NED and Chair appointments at insurance firms, see our sister firm NED Capital.

For UK insurance regulatory and market context, see Lloyd’s of London, PRA Prudential Regulation guidance, and the FCA Senior Managers and Certification Regime. For UK insurance industry data and trade body resources, see the Association of British Insurers (ABI), the UK insurance trade body, the British Insurance Brokers’ Association (BIBA) for the broking sector, and the Lloyd’s Market Association (LMA) for the Lloyd’s market specifically.

Planning a senior insurance appointment?

Tell us about the role — from a Chief Underwriting Officer at a managing agent to a fractional SMF16 for a broker or MGA — and we will work through segment, format and approval with you. You can also contact us directly.

Tell us about your hire

Call 0203 834 9616 · recruitment@execcapital.co.uk

Related Insurance Search Services

Exec Capital places insurance leaders on permanent, interim and fractional terms across the UK. Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.

PRACTICE AREA

Underwriting Leadership


Chief Underwriting Officers, Active Underwriters and underwriting teams across insurers, MGAs and syndicates.

→ Chief Underwriting Officer

→ SMF23 CUO Recruitment

→ Insurance Underwriter Recruitment

→ Lloyd’s of London Underwriters


SMF20 and SMF23 explained →

PRACTICE AREA

Actuarial, Risk and Reinsurance


Chief Actuaries, Chief Risk Officers and senior reinsurance professionals for PRA-authorised firms.

→ SMF20 Chief Actuary

→ Chief Risk Officer Recruitment

→ Reinsurance Recruitment


SMF4 CRO hiring guide →

PRACTICE AREA

Fractional Compliance for Brokers and MGAs


Fractional and interim SMF16 and SMF17 cover for FCA-regulated intermediaries and smaller insurers.

→ Fractional CCO

→ Fractional Compliance Officer

→ Interim CCO

→ Fractional MLRO


SMF16 vs SMF17 guide →

PRACTICE AREA

Insurance Boards and Regulated Firms


Board, NED and senior manager appointments at insurers and other FCA and PRA-regulated firms.

→ FCA-Regulated Firm Recruitment

→ NED Recruitment

→ Asset Management Recruitment


Insurance board appointments under SMCR →


Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.

About the author

Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name, with more than 25 years at C-suite level, and a graduate of Queen Mary, University of London. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what senior leadership hires actually require. View Adrian’s ICAEW profile.

Start a search

Tell us about your Insurance hire

Share a few details about the role and your timetable. Our executive search team will review your brief and come back to you the same working day.

  • Same-day response from the team that runs our C-suite and board searches
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Permanent, interim and fractional C-suite and director roles across the UK

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.