The Head of Internal Audit is one of the most structurally complex appointments a regulated firm can make. Under SMCR, where the role is a designated senior management function — SMF5 — the individual carries personal regulatory accountability for the internal audit function. But the complexity goes beyond the regulatory designation. Internal audit must be genuinely independent of the business it reviews, and that independence requirement shapes everything from reporting lines to remuneration structure to the candidate profile itself.
Exec Capital works with FCA-authorised firms to identify Heads of Internal Audit who combine the technical depth the role demands with the personal authority to operate independently of management and report directly and effectively to the Audit Committee. This guide sets out what firms need to consider before opening a Head of Internal Audit search, including the SMCR changes that took effect in April 2026 and the further reforms the FCA and PRA are now consulting on. If you already know you need to hire, our Head of Internal Audit recruitment service sets out how we run these searches.
SMF5: What the Designation Covers
Not every Head of Internal Audit at an FCA-authorised firm holds the SMF5 designation. SMF5 is a prescribed senior management function only at two groups of firm: PRA-regulated firms (banks, building societies, PRA-designated investment firms and insurers), where it is a PRA function, and FCA solo-regulated firms that fall into the Enhanced category of the SMCR. Core and Limited Scope solo-regulated firms do not have an SMF5, even where they run a capable internal audit function. At those firms the role can still be significant, and the individual may hold other accountabilities, but there is no separate SMF5 approval to obtain.
That distinction matters more than it used to. From 10 July 2026 the FCA raised certain of the financial thresholds that determine whether a solo-regulated firm is Enhanced, to reflect inflation since the regime was introduced. Some firms near the old thresholds may now sit in the Core category and no longer need an SMF5; others that are growing will cross the new thresholds and need one for the first time. Before opening a search, confirm which category the firm is in and whether the role being filled is a prescribed function at all. Our overview of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime explains the firm categories in more detail.
Where SMF5 applies, the individual must currently be approved before taking up the role. At a dual-regulated firm the application goes to the PRA, which approves with the FCA’s consent; at an Enhanced solo-regulated firm it goes to the FCA. The regulators assess the candidate’s fitness and propriety, including regulatory history, criminal record checks and any material disclosures. The statutory period for deciding a complete application is three months, and an incomplete application can take longer, so firms should build the approval stage into the search timetable rather than treating it as an afterthought.
The Statement of Responsibilities for an SMF5 appointment should reflect the genuine scope of the internal audit function, including any co-sourcing or outsourcing arrangements. Where part of the internal audit function is provided by an external firm, the SoR should make clear that the SMF5 holder retains oversight responsibility for the quality and independence of that external work. The regulators expect this to be explicit, not implied.
SMCR Changes in 2026 and What They Mean for SMF5
The SMCR is part-way through a two-phase review. Phase one is already in force; phase two is out to consultation. Both affect how a Head of Internal Audit appointment is run.
Phase one: in force since 24 April 2026
The FCA’s PS26/6 on the SMCR review, published alongside matching PRA rules, made a set of practical changes, most of them effective from 24 April 2026. The ones that matter most for an SMF5 hire are:
- The 12-week rule. Where a firm needs someone to cover an unexpected SMF vacancy, it now has 12 weeks to submit an application for that person, rather than 12 weeks to submit and obtain approval. The individual can continue to act while the application is decided. This makes interim cover for an unplanned SMF5 vacancy considerably less fraught.
- Criminal record checks. A check now stays valid for six months rather than three, and checks are no longer needed for internal or intra-group moves — useful where the preferred candidate is moving across from a group entity.
- Statements of Responsibilities. Firms no longer have to resubmit an SoR every time something changes; they have up to six months after a significant change to notify it.
- Regulatory references. The period for responding to a reference request has been shortened, which should help the referencing stage of an SMF5 process move faster.
Phase two: proposals published 22 October 2026
The FCA’s consultation paper CP26/37 and the PRA’s CP14/26 go further. Among other things they propose that a group of senior manager functions — SMF5 Head of Internal Audit among them, alongside the committee chair roles such as SMF11 Chair of the Audit Committee — would no longer need regulatory pre-approval. Instead, the firm would assess the individual’s fitness and propriety itself and notify the regulator. The proposals would also remove the Certification Regime and, in the PRA’s case, extend the temporary cover period from 12 to 18 weeks.
These are proposals only. Both consultations close on 22 January 2027, the regulators expect to make final rules in 2027 with implementation expected in the second half of 2027, and much of the package depends on the Financial Services and Markets Bill passing in its current form. Until then, SMF5 remains a pre-approved function. Even if the change goes ahead, it would shift the fitness and propriety assessment onto the firm rather than remove it — which raises the importance of a properly documented selection, vetting and referencing process, not lowers it. A board that appoints an SMF5 under a notification regime will need to be able to show the regulator why it was satisfied.
The Independence Requirement
The regulators expect the internal audit function to be independent of the activities it reviews. In practice, this has significant implications for how the role is structured and who can credibly hold it. A candidate who has spent their career in the first or second line at the same firm — or who has close relationships with the management team they will be required to audit — starts the role with a structural credibility problem that no governance framework can fully compensate for.
The most effective SMF5 appointments are individuals who report directly to the Audit Committee chair with an administrative line to the CEO or CFO. They attend board and Audit Committee meetings as of right, have unrestricted access to records and personnel, and have a remuneration structure that is not materially influenced by the outcomes of the business units they review. Where any of these conditions is missing, the supervisory team is likely to notice.
The independence requirement also has implications for the candidate’s previous employer relationships. Where an HIA candidate has previously worked at the firm in a business role — particularly in the first or second line — boards should consider carefully whether that prior relationship creates a perception issue with the regulator, even if the individual is technically qualified for the role. The fitness and propriety assessment looks at independence of mind as well as structural independence.
The same logic applies to candidates moving across from the external auditor. Someone who led the statutory audit of the firm, or who worked closely on it, may know the business well, but the board should think about any cooling-off period and how the move will look to the regulator and to the external audit firm before making an offer.
Hiring a Head of Internal Audit?
Exec Capital finds Heads of Internal Audit with the independence, technical depth and Audit Committee presence that SMF5 roles at regulated firms demand.
The FCA’s Approach to Internal Audit at Regulated Firms
The regulators’ supervisory approach to internal audit has moved a long way over the past decade. They now expect to see evidence that internal audit is providing genuine challenge to management, not simply confirming that processes are being followed. Audit reports that are consistently positive, that rarely identify material control weaknesses, or that are not followed up with disciplined management action tracking are indicators of a function that may be too close to the business it is reviewing.
Supervisory commentary and industry guidance return to the same recurring concerns: internal audit functions that lack the technical expertise to audit complex risk areas such as model risk, operational resilience or financial crime; functions that are under-resourced relative to the complexity of the business; and functions that have insufficient access to senior management to escalate concerns effectively. Firms that have received regulatory commentary on any of these issues need to factor that context into the HIA appointment brief, because the new appointee will be expected to fix it.
The regulators also pay attention to the internal audit function’s relationship with the external auditor and with the second line. Where internal audit, risk, compliance and external audit are not well coordinated — where there is duplication, gaps, or tension between them — the quality of the overall assurance framework is weakened. Strong HIA candidates understand how to manage these relationships productively. That includes working alongside the Chief Risk Officer without becoming an extension of the risk function; our guide to the SMF4 Chief Risk Officer function covers that role from the other side.
Professional Standards: The Global Internal Audit Standards and the Chartered IIA Code
Two professional frameworks sit behind what a regulated firm’s board should expect from its Head of Internal Audit. The first is the Institute of Internal Auditors’ Global Internal Audit Standards, which became effective on 9 January 2025. They give more weight than the previous framework to internal audit strategy, stakeholder relationships and performance measurement, and they set out governance conditions — including the board’s role in supporting and overseeing the function — that the standards treat as essential to effective internal auditing.
The second is the Chartered Institute of Internal Auditors’ Internal Audit Code of Practice, effective from January 2025. It is a single, principles-based code covering the financial services, private and third sectors, and it builds on the Internal Audit Financial Services Code, which was last revised in 2021 and remains a familiar reference point for financial services audit committees. The Code is intended to be applied alongside the Global Internal Audit Standards and any regulatory requirements that apply to the firm.
For a hiring board, the practical point is that a credible candidate should be able to explain how their function measures up against both frameworks: how the internal audit charter and mandate are agreed with the Audit Committee, how the audit plan covers risk culture, conduct and emerging risks as well as financial controls, and how quality is assessed internally and through external quality assessment. A candidate who cannot speak fluently to these points is unlikely to satisfy a regulator that expects the function to meet professional standards.
What the Right Candidate Looks Like
The Head of Internal Audit at an FCA-regulated firm typically has a background in one or more of the following: external audit at a major accounting firm with financial services clients, an internal audit leadership role at another regulated firm, or a risk function role that has involved significant audit committee exposure. Professional qualifications — CMIIA, ACA, ACCA — are common but not universal. Sector matters too: an HIA from a retail bank will understand credit, conduct and financial crime risk; one from an insurer will know reserving, underwriting controls and Solvency II reporting; one from an asset manager will know investment operations and client money.
Beyond technical credentials, the regulated firm HIA must be able to present complex audit findings to a board audience that includes non-executive directors who may not have operational backgrounds. They must be prepared to escalate concerns about management behaviour or control failures without hesitation. And they must be capable of maintaining a productive working relationship with a management team that may not always welcome their conclusions.
Candidates who have led internal audit functions through a significant regulatory review, a material control failure, or a period of rapid business change are particularly valuable. The audit function’s quality is most visible under pressure, and firms benefit from appointing individuals who have been tested in that way. Interview processes should specifically explore what candidates did when they found something significant — how they reported it, how they managed the management response, and how they followed up to ensure remediation was genuine.
Useful areas to probe at interview include:
- Risk-based planning. How the candidate builds and flexes the audit plan, and what they have dropped from a plan to make room for an emerging risk.
- Specialist coverage. How they have audited areas outside their own expertise, such as technology, models or financial crime, and when they chose to bring in specialist support.
- Escalation. A specific occasion when they took a finding over management’s head to the Audit Committee chair, and what happened next.
- Regulator contact. Direct experience of meeting the FCA or PRA supervisory team and how they prepared.
Reporting Lines and Audit Committee Dynamics
The relationship between the Head of Internal Audit and the Audit Committee chair is central to the effectiveness of the function. Before opening a search, boards should assess whether the current Audit Committee chair has the time, the appetite, and the expertise to provide the oversight the SMF5 role requires. A technically strong HIA with a passive or disengaged Audit Committee will struggle to fulfil the regulatory expectations of the function regardless of their individual competence. Our guide to hiring an SMF11 Chair of the Audit Committee covers the other half of this relationship.
Where the Audit Committee chair is new to the role or lacks deep familiarity with regulated firm audit requirements, it is worth considering whether a brief — setting out the regulators’ expectations of the internal audit function — would be useful before the search begins. Exec Capital can provide that briefing as part of the engagement. Where the committee itself needs strengthening, we also run financial services non-executive searches for audit and risk committee members.
The frequency and format of Audit Committee reporting is also worth reviewing before the appointment is made. An HIA who is expected to provide quarterly written reports to the Committee, without regular informal dialogue between meetings, is operating in a more constrained environment than one who has regular access to the chair outside of formal meetings. The best-governed internal audit functions have a clear protocol for escalating urgent findings between scheduled committee meetings, and HIA candidates should expect to be asked how they would operate within the firm’s existing governance arrangements. In groups, it is also worth settling early how the subsidiary HIA relates to the group Chief Audit Executive, and who sets the audit plan for the regulated entity.
Co-Sourcing and the HIA’s Oversight Role
Many regulated firms use a co-sourcing model for internal audit, where part of the function is delivered by an external professional services firm. This is a legitimate and often effective model, particularly where the firm’s risk profile requires specialised audit expertise that it would be difficult to maintain on a permanent basis. However, the co-sourcing arrangement does not reduce the SMF5 holder’s accountability — they remain personally responsible for the quality and independence of all internal audit work, including work delivered by external co-source partners.
HIA candidates who have managed co-sourced audit functions need to demonstrate that they have the skills and the relationship management capability to hold external providers to account — to challenge audit programmes, review work quality, and escalate concerns where the external firm’s work does not meet the required standard. A passive SMF5 holder who relies on the external firm to set the agenda is not meeting the regulatory expectation of the designation. Boards should also check for conflicts: a co-source provider that also advises management on the same controls it is auditing creates exactly the independence problem the function exists to avoid.
Compensation Benchmarks
Head of Internal Audit pay at FCA-authorised firms varies widely with the size and complexity of the firm, its sector, whether the role carries the SMF5 designation and whether the HIA also leads a group function. Rather than relying on a single published range, firms should benchmark the role against the specific peer group they are hiring from and against their own senior control function roles. We share current market data with clients at the briefing stage of each search.
Structure matters as much as level. At firms subject to the Remuneration Code, internal audit is a control function, and pay for control function staff should be set by reference to the objectives of the function rather than the performance of the business areas it reviews. Senior managers are generally identified as material risk takers, so variable pay for an SMF5 holder will normally be subject to the firm’s deferral, malus and clawback arrangements. Candidates moving from a firm with a different remuneration regime will want to understand what that means for them before accepting an offer, and some will have deferred awards from their current employer that the new firm needs to consider.
Firms that underprice the HIA role relative to equivalent functions in the first and second lines will find the candidate market limited and will typically attract individuals who lack the authority to operate effectively within the governance structure. The internal audit function’s credibility is partly a function of how it is perceived within the firm’s pay hierarchy. Where the HIA is materially less well paid than the CRO or the CCO, it sends a signal — internally and externally — about the firm’s commitment to genuine independence of assurance.
Succession Planning for the HIA Role
Internal audit succession is frequently undermanaged at regulated firms. The combination of the independence requirement, the regulatory approval obligation, and the specialist nature of the role means that a vacancy in the HIA function — particularly an unplanned one — creates both a governance gap and a regulatory notification obligation. Firms should have a clear succession plan for the SMF5 holder and should have identified interim coverage arrangements that can be activated at short notice. The April 2026 change to the 12-week rule helps here: an interim can step in and act while the firm’s application is being decided, provided the application is made within the 12 weeks.
Internal successors need particular care. A deputy who has grown up inside the function may be technically ready, but the board should be confident they will be seen as independent of a management team they have worked alongside for years. Many boards also set an expected tenure for the HIA and revisit independence and freshness of challenge periodically. Where the HIA is approaching the end of a planned tenure, succession planning should begin well in advance — we suggest at least eighteen months. The regulatory approval timeline for an SMF5 appointment, combined with the need to allow an adequate handover period and any notice period of six months or more at senior level, means that a late start carries real risk.
The Search Process
Exec Capital approaches Head of Internal Audit searches at FCA-regulated firms on a retained basis, as part of our wider compliance and risk recruitment practice. We maintain relationships with experienced internal audit leaders across banking, insurance, asset management and consumer finance, and we prioritise candidates who have direct experience of operating under FCA or PRA supervision. We typically present a shortlist of four to five candidates, supported by detailed reference conversations that go beyond standard written references to explore how candidates have handled the most demanding aspects of the role.
Where SMF5 applies, we support the firm through the regulatory approval process and provide guidance on Statement of Responsibilities drafting to ensure the designation accurately reflects the individual’s scope and accountability. Where the firm is hiring across its control functions at the same time — for example, an HIA alongside a Chief Risk Officer — we can run the searches together through our CRO recruitment team so that the two appointments complement each other. For more on how we work on this role specifically, see our Head of Internal Audit search for FCA-regulated firms.
Frequently asked questions
Which firms need an SMF5 Head of Internal Audit?
PRA-regulated firms, such as banks, building societies, PRA-designated investment firms and insurers, and FCA solo-regulated firms in the Enhanced SMCR category. Core and Limited Scope firms do not have an SMF5 function.
Does an SMF5 still need regulatory approval?
Yes, for now. CP26/37 and PRA CP14/26 propose moving SMF5 to a notification regime, but these are proposals only, with implementation expected in the second half of 2027 at the earliest and subject to legislation.
Who should the Head of Internal Audit report to?
Primarily to the Audit Committee chair, with an administrative reporting line to the CEO or CFO. The HIA should have unrestricted access to records, people and the board.
Can we cover an unexpected SMF5 vacancy with an interim?
Yes. Since 24 April 2026, firms have 12 weeks to submit an SMF application for the person covering, and that person can continue to act until the application is decided.
Does co-sourcing reduce the SMF5 holder’s accountability?
No. The SMF5 holder remains responsible for the quality and independence of all internal audit work, including work delivered by an external co-source provider, and the Statement of Responsibilities should say so.
Need a Head of Internal Audit who will stand up to scrutiny?
Exec Capital places Heads of Internal Audit and other SMF holders at FCA and PRA-regulated firms, on permanent and interim terms.
Related Regulated Executive Search Services
Exec Capital places control function leaders, SMF holders and board members at FCA and PRA-regulated firms on permanent, interim and fractional terms. Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.
PRACTICE AREA
Internal Audit & Assurance
Heads of Internal Audit and senior assurance leaders who can operate independently of management.
→ Head of Internal Audit Recruitment
→ Compliance & Risk Recruitment
PRACTICE AREA
Risk & Compliance Leadership
Chief Risk Officers and Heads of Compliance for the second line alongside internal audit.
→ SMF16 Head of Compliance Recruitment
PRACTICE AREA
Boards & Audit Committees
Non-executive directors and committee chairs who give internal audit the oversight it needs.
→ Financial Services Non-Executive Recruitment
→ Insurance Board Appointments (SMCR)
PRACTICE AREA
Interim & Urgent SMF Cover
Experienced interim leaders to hold a senior manager function while a permanent hire is made.
→ Interim Executive Recruitment
Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.
About the author
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name, with more than 25 years’ experience operating at C-suite level. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what senior leadership hires actually require. View Adrian’s ICAEW profile.
Related posts:
How long does FCA SMF approval actually take? A realistic timeline for regulated firm boards
Recruiting a CEO for an FCA-Authorised Firm: What Makes the Brief Different
Hiring Into a Senior Manager Function: What the Approval Gate Changes
Why Your Compliance Hire Keeps Falling Through (And What to Do About It)
Insurer and Insurance Intermediary Senior Hiring: The Lloyd’s Market and FCA Dimension
SMF13 Chair of Nominations Committee
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant and holds an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name with over 25 years’ experience operating at C-suite level, Adrian brings direct executive experience to senior search. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies, and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what leadership hires actually require.