Senior Board Appointments at Challenger Banks: SMCR, PRA Expectations and the Talent Pool

Updated 4 November 2026

How challenger banks approach senior board appointments under SMCR and dual PRA/FCA regulation — talent availability, approval timelines and the search brief.

  • Founded by Adrian Lawrence FCA, ICAEW
  • Permanent, interim and fractional C-suite hires
  • Offices in London and the West Midlands
Senior Board Appointments at Challenger Banks: SMCR, PRA Expectations and the Talent Pool

Senior appointments at challenger banks sit in one of the most demanding regulatory environments in UK financial services. The combination of FCA and PRA oversight — dual regulation — means that every senior management function appointment is subject to heightened scrutiny, and the personal accountability framework that applies to senior managers is more intensive than at FCA-only firms. Getting a board appointment wrong at a challenger bank is not simply a commercial inconvenience. It can draw supervisory attention to the entire firm at exactly the moment when the business needs to be demonstrating stability and maturity to the regulator.

Exec Capital works with challenger banks and neo-banks at various stages of authorisation and growth to identify and place executives and non-executive directors who understand the dual-regulated environment, through our financial services executive search practice. This guide addresses what challenger bank boards and investors need to understand before approaching a senior appointment — including the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) reforms that took effect in April 2026 and the further changes the regulators proposed in October 2026.

Dual Regulation: What It Changes

UK banks, including challenger banks, are regulated by both the FCA and the PRA. The FCA’s focus is primarily on conduct — how the firm treats its customers, the quality of its disclosures, and whether it operates within its permissions. The PRA’s focus is primarily on prudential matters — capital adequacy, liquidity, risk governance, and the firm’s overall safety and soundness. Both regulators have a role in senior manager approvals: the PRA leads on the functions it specifies, and the FCA must give its consent before the PRA makes a final decision on a dual-regulated firm’s application.

In practice, PRA approval for senior appointments tends to involve a more intensive review than FCA approval alone. The PRA is particularly focused on the individual’s understanding of prudential risks, their experience managing capital and liquidity under stress, and their capacity to engage constructively with supervisory dialogue. Candidates who have only worked in FCA-only regulated environments may find the PRA approval process more challenging than they expect, and firms should factor this into their assessment of the candidate’s suitability before progressing to the offer stage.

For challenger bank boards, this means that the candidate pool is narrower than it first appears. Not everyone with strong financial services experience is familiar with dual regulation, and not everyone familiar with dual regulation has operated at the level the role requires. Identifying candidates who combine seniority, dual-regulation experience, and the right technical background is the core challenge of a challenger bank senior appointment.

Dual regulation also changes the shape of accountability inside the firm. Each senior manager carries a Statement of Responsibilities, and the firm maintains a management responsibilities map showing how prescribed responsibilities are allocated. At a small challenger bank, a handful of individuals may hold most of those responsibilities between them, so a weak hire in one seat leaves gaps that the rest of the team cannot easily absorb.

Authorisation and Mobilisation: The First Senior Team

For a new bank, the first board and executive appointments are part of the authorisation case itself. The PRA and FCA’s New Bank Start-up Unit offers a mobilisation route — authorisation with restrictions — in which a firm is authorised but its deposit-taking is capped while it completes its build. The Bank of England says mobilisation should take no longer than 12 months and limits total deposits during that period to £50,000.

Recruitment is one of the activities the regulators expect to be completed during mobilisation. The Bank of England’s guidance describes the minimum senior team at that stage as the board chair, the CEO and one other executive, usually the CFO, with senior appointments finalised early. The firm also has to complete its risk, internal audit and compliance functions before exiting mobilisation, which in practice means the Chief Risk Officer, the head of compliance and the internal audit arrangements need to be settled well before the variation of permission application to lift the restrictions.

This sequencing matters for hiring. A chair who has taken a bank through authorisation before will usually shape the rest of the board, and the CEO and CFO appointments define the credibility of the business plan in front of the regulators. Our guide to CEO appointments at challenger banks covers the SMF1 decision in more detail, and the chair of a regulated firm search is often the first appointment we discuss with founders and investors.

The Talent Pool: What Is Available and Where

The senior talent pool for challenger bank appointments draws from several sources. Established banks — both domestic and international — provide a significant proportion of the candidates who move into challenger bank executive roles. Their experience of operating within a mature prudential framework is valuable, though boards should assess carefully whether candidates from large-institution backgrounds can adapt to the resource constraints, pace, and culture of a growth-stage business. An individual who has spent their career in a large bank’s risk or finance function may find the breadth of accountability at a challenger bank significantly more challenging than their seniority would suggest.

The challenger bank sector itself has now been active long enough to have produced a meaningful cohort of executives with direct experience at similar firms. These individuals — who have lived through authorisation, capital raises, regulatory reviews, and rapid scaling — are the most sought-after candidates in the market. Firms seeking to recruit from this cohort need to move quickly and offer a clear story about where the business is going, because these candidates have options and make their decisions as much on strategic fit as on compensation.

Professional services firms — particularly those with financial services regulatory practices — are a third source. Partners and directors who have advised challenger banks through authorisation, remediation programmes, or capital transactions sometimes make effective transitions into executive roles, bringing both regulatory expertise and an external perspective on the firm’s position. This profile works particularly well for CFO and CRO roles, where the analytical and regulatory dimensions of the background are most directly relevant; our page on CRO recruitment at challenger banks sets out what the PRA looks for in an SMF4.

A fourth source is the wider fintech and payments sector. Leaders from e-money institutions, lenders and payment firms often bring the product, technology and customer-acquisition experience a digital bank needs, but most have worked only under FCA supervision. They can be strong appointments where the prudential seats are already filled by bank-trained people; our fintech recruitment work regularly crosses into this part of the market.

Appointing a board member or senior manager at a challenger bank?

Exec Capital runs discreet searches for executives and NEDs with dual-regulated experience, and supports clients through the PRA and FCA approval process.

Financial Services Executive Search →Tell us about your hire

NED Appointments: Independence and PRA Expectations

Non-executive director appointments at challenger banks require a separate assessment. The PRA expects NEDs to be genuinely independent and to provide effective challenge to management on prudential matters. This expectation goes beyond the standard independence criteria applied in corporate governance — the PRA wants to see NEDs who understand the prudential framework well enough to identify when management’s position on capital adequacy, liquidity risk, or risk appetite is not conservative enough, and who have the confidence and authority to say so.

Candidates who have served as NEDs at established banks, building societies, or insurers are typically better positioned for the PRA approval process than those with purely commercial non-executive backgrounds. However, the regulatory background alone is not sufficient — NEDs at challenger banks need to add genuine value in a growth-stage context, which requires both the credibility to challenge management effectively and the strategic awareness to support the firm’s development ambitions without compromising on prudential standards. Our financial services NED recruitment searches are built around that combination.

The composition of the board’s committees — particularly the Risk Committee, the Audit Committee, and the Remuneration Committee — is closely scrutinised by the PRA. The regulator expects each committee to be chaired by an NED with relevant expertise and to have sufficient independent membership to provide genuine oversight. Challenger bank boards that have grown rapidly may find that their committee composition does not yet meet the PRA’s standards, and NED appointments should be sequenced to address specific gaps rather than simply to add board capacity. The Chair of the Risk Committee is usually the hardest of these seats to fill; see our SMF10 Chair of the Risk Committee hiring guide.

PRA Expectations at Different Stages of Growth

The PRA’s supervisory approach to challenger banks is not uniform — it reflects the firm’s stage of development, its risk profile, and its track record in engaging with the regulator. A newly authorised challenger bank faces a different supervisory lens than one that has been operating for several years and is approaching profitability. Board appointments need to be calibrated accordingly.

At earlier stages, the PRA places significant weight on the quality of the senior team relative to the complexity of the firm’s business model. A challenger bank with an ambitious product roadmap and a thin executive team will face persistent supervisory pressure to strengthen its leadership. Boards that address this early — bringing in experienced executives before the PRA raises the issue formally — tend to manage their regulatory relationships more effectively than those that wait for a regulatory prompt.

As challenger banks mature and seek to expand their permissions or product range, the PRA’s expectations of the board’s collective competence increase. The composition of the Risk Committee, the Audit Committee, and the board itself becomes a live supervisory topic, and appointment decisions are scrutinised in that context. Boards seeking to expand into new product areas — retail deposits, mortgage lending, embedded finance — should consider whether the existing board composition is appropriate for the new risk profile before submitting variation of permission applications.

The Strong and Simple regime for smaller banks

Stage of growth now has a formal prudential dimension. Under its Strong and Simple framework, the PRA published PS4/26 in January 2026, setting out the final simplified capital regime for Small Domestic Deposit Takers (SDDTs). The SDDT capital regime takes effect on 1 January 2027, and eligibility is set by criteria in the PRA Rulebook. A simpler regime is not a lighter test of people. The board still has to judge whether the firm qualifies, whether to opt in, and what happens to its capital position if growth takes it outside the criteria. CFOs and CROs who understand both the SDDT rules and the full framework are worth more to a scaling bank than specialists in only one.

The SMF Approval Process and PRA Interviews

Applications for pre-approved senior manager functions at a bank go to the PRA through its Connect system. On its Senior Managers Regime approvals page, the PRA says it has a statutory obligation to review an application in the 90 days following receipt, and that the clock stops while it waits for further information or for an interview to take place. A firm that does not respond to an information request in four weeks may be treated as a non-responder and the application rejected.

The PRA may interview candidates as part of its assessment, particularly for the most senior roles at the largest firms. Where both regulators want to interview, they aim to hold one joint interview. Challenger bank boards should not assume a small firm means no interview: a first-time SMF holder, a candidate moving into banking from another sector, or a firm already under supervisory pressure all make an interview more likely. Preparation is part of a well-run search — the candidate needs to speak to the firm’s business model, risk appetite, capital and liquidity position, and their own Statement of Responsibilities with confidence. Our guide to how long SMF approval takes covers planning start dates around the process.

SM&CR Reform: What Has Changed and What Is Proposed

The regime is changing in two phases. Phase 1 was finalised in April 2026 through PRA PS12/26 and FCA PS26/6, with most changes taking effect on 24 April 2026. These were process changes rather than a redesign: amendments to the rules on temporarily performing a senior manager function under the 12-week rule, a longer validity period for criminal record checks on SMF applications (with no new check needed for an existing SMF holder moving role within the same group), and lighter requirements for submitting updated Statements of Responsibilities and responsibilities maps.

Phase 2 is still a proposal. On 22 October 2026 the PRA published CP14/26, alongside a parallel FCA consultation, with responses due by 22 January 2027. The proposals that matter most for challenger bank boards are:

  • Committee chairs and the SID moving to notification. The PRA proposes that the Chairs of the Risk, Audit and Remuneration Committees (SMF10, SMF11, SMF12) and the Senior Independent Director (SMF14), among others, would no longer need pre-approval. The firm would assess fitness and propriety and notify the regulator.
  • Core roles staying pre-approved. The CEO (SMF1), CFO (SMF2), CRO (SMF4) and Chair (SMF9) would remain subject to pre-approval under the PRA’s proposals.
  • Longer temporary cover. The period for covering an SMF without approval would extend from 12 to 18 weeks, still for situations that were reasonably unforeseen.
  • Certification Regime removed. Annual certification would be replaced by an ongoing duty to make sure relevant staff have the necessary competence, integrity and honesty.

The PRA expects implementation in the second half of 2027, subject to the necessary legislation passing and being commenced by HM Treasury. Until then the current rules apply. Even if the proposals are adopted, moving a role to notification shifts the burden of assessment onto the firm rather than removing it. A board that appoints a Risk Committee chair without pre-approval still carries responsibility for that person being fit and proper, and the PRA can still challenge an appointment it considers weak. Search diligence on NED and committee roles becomes more important, not less.

MRIAs, VREQs and the Impact on Senior Hiring

Challenger banks that have received formal supervisory findings — often described in the market as Matters Requiring Immediate Attention (MRIAs) — voluntary requirements (VREQs) agreed with the FCA, requirements imposed by the PRA, or skilled person reviews face a particular challenge in senior hiring. Regulatory remediation creates urgent demand for executives and NEDs with specific expertise — in operational resilience, financial crime, capital adequacy, or other areas identified in the regulatory action — while simultaneously making the firm less attractive to some candidates who are concerned about reputational risk.

Positioning the opportunity accurately is the main task in these searches. Candidates need an honest account of the regulatory issue, what has already been done, and what the role is expected to fix. Those with specific remediation experience generally understand that these situations, managed well, can be career-defining. A remediation hire also changes the approval conversation: the regulator will want to see that the incoming senior manager has the skills to close the specific findings, so the brief should be written around them rather than around a generic job description.

The Investor Perspective on Board Composition

Venture capital and private equity investors in challenger banks have their own view of board composition, which does not always align precisely with the PRA’s expectations. Investors typically want board members who can add commercial value — who bring network, sector expertise, or strategic insight that accelerates the firm’s growth. The PRA, meanwhile, is primarily focused on the board’s ability to provide prudential oversight and independent challenge to management.

Managing this tension — building a board that satisfies both investors and regulators — is one of the most important governance challenges at a challenger bank. The most effective approach is to ensure that the executive team carries most of the commercial value-creation responsibility, while the NED appointments are sequenced to meet the PRA’s prudential oversight expectations. Investor representatives on the board need to understand the dual-regulated environment and to appreciate that the PRA will scrutinise their conduct as board members regardless of their status as shareholders.

Compensation and Appetite

Senior executive compensation at challenger banks reflects both the regulatory demands of the role and the commercial risk the individual is taking by joining a growth-stage business. At venture and growth-backed firms, equity participation — options or warrants — usually forms a material part of the overall package, and candidates from established bank backgrounds often accept a lower base salary in exchange for equity and the opportunity to build something. The trade-off only works if the equity story is credible, so the funding position and the route to profitability need to be explained clearly at an early stage of the process.

Non-executive fees vary with the size of the bank, the time commitment and whether the NED chairs a committee. The PRA’s remuneration requirements — including deferral and malus provisions for material risk takers — apply across the senior population and need to be reflected in offer structures from the outset. Firms that design remuneration structures without adequate regulatory advice frequently find themselves restructuring them later, at a cost, once the issue becomes apparent. Candidates moving from a larger bank will also want to understand how any deferred awards they forfeit by leaving will be treated, and buy-out arrangements need to fit the same rules.

Working with Exec Capital on Challenger Bank Appointments

Exec Capital approaches senior appointments at challenger banks with a clear understanding of the regulatory environment and the talent dynamics of the sector. We work on a retained basis and manage the search process to reflect the dual-regulation timeline — including support through PRA and FCA approval processes, interview preparation and input on Statement of Responsibilities drafting. We maintain relationships with executives and non-executives who have direct challenger bank experience, and we make discreet approaches that protect both the firm’s position in the market and the candidates’ current relationships. To discuss a board or executive appointment, see our financial services executive search service or contact the team directly.

Frequently asked questions

Which senior appointments does a new bank need in place first?

The Bank of England describes the minimum senior team during mobilisation as the board chair, the CEO and one other executive, usually the CFO. Risk, compliance and internal audit functions must also be completed before the bank exits mobilisation.

Does the PRA interview SMF candidates at challenger banks?

It may. The PRA says it interviews candidates where appropriate, particularly for the most senior roles at the largest firms, and aims for a joint interview where the FCA also wants one. Smaller banks should still prepare candidates on the assumption that an interview could be requested.

Will committee chairs still need PRA approval?

For now, yes. Under CP14/26, published in October 2026, the PRA proposes moving SMF10, SMF11, SMF12 and SMF14 to a notification regime. These are proposals; implementation is expected in the second half of 2027 at the earliest, subject to legislation.

Does the SDDT regime change who a small bank should hire?

It changes what the CFO and CRO need to understand. The simplified SDDT capital regime takes effect on 1 January 2027, and the board must manage eligibility and the transition if the bank grows beyond the criteria.

Can a fintech executive become a challenger bank senior manager?

Yes, but the PRA will test their prudential knowledge. Fintech leaders tend to work best in commercial or operational roles, with bank-trained people in the CFO, CRO and risk committee seats.

Planning a board or senior manager appointment at a challenger bank?

Exec Capital places executives and non-executive directors at challenger banks and dual-regulated firms, with support through the PRA and FCA approval process.

Tell us about your hire

Call 0203 834 9616 · recruitment@execcapital.co.uk

Related Banking and Financial Services Search

Exec Capital places executives and non-executive directors at banks, fintechs and other FCA and PRA regulated firms across the UK. Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.

PRACTICE AREA

Banking & Financial Services


Senior appointments at banks, lenders and dual-regulated firms.

→ Financial Services Executive Search

→ Commercial Banking Recruitment


Financial services hiring guide →

PRACTICE AREA

Chairs & Non-Executives


Independent chairs and NEDs who can meet PRA expectations of challenge.

→ Chair of a Regulated Firm

→ Financial Services NED Recruitment


First-time chair approval guide →

PRACTICE AREA

Executive Senior Managers


CEO and CRO appointments that must pass PRA and FCA approval.

→ CEO of a Regulated Firm

→ CRO Recruitment


CEO appointments at challenger banks →

PRACTICE AREA

Committees & Fintech


Senior Independent Directors and fintech leaders for growing digital banks.

→ Senior Independent Director (SMF14)

→ Fintech Recruitment


SMF10 Chair of Risk Committee guide →


Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.

About the author

Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name, with more than 25 years’ experience operating at C-suite level. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what senior leadership hires actually require. View Adrian’s ICAEW profile.

Start a search

Tell us about your executive hire

Share a few details about the role and your timetable. Our executive search team will review your brief and come back to you the same working day.

  • Same-day response from the team that runs our C-suite and board searches
  • Confidential from the first conversation, with no obligation to proceed
  • Permanent, interim and fractional C-suite and director roles across the UK

Your details are used only to respond to your enquiry.