The first ninety days of a Chief Operating Officer’s tenure decide more than most boards expect. Not because the important work happens in that window — it rarely does — but because the organisation forms a view of the appointment within about six weeks, and that view is difficult to revise afterwards. The senior team decides whether the new COO is someone whose instructions count, the chief executive decides whether they can genuinely let go, and the board decides whether the hire was the right one.
This is a practical transition plan: what to settle before you start, what to audit, who to meet and in what order, when to form a view on the team, what your first board paper should say, which early win to choose and which structural problems to leave until you have earned the right to fix them. It also covers two situations the standard advice ignores — the COO who takes on a senior manager function in an FCA-regulated firm, and the interim or fractional COO who has to compress the whole cycle into a much shorter or thinner window. It is written by a firm that handles COO recruitment and sees which transitions hold and which do not.
Before day one
Two conversations are worth having before you start, and both are easier before you are an employee.
Settle decision rights with the CEO in writing. Which decisions are yours, which are theirs, which go to the board, and what your approval threshold is. This is the single commonest cause of COO failure and the only point at which it is comfortable to raise. A chief executive who cannot name three decisions they will stop making is not yet ready for the appointment, and it is better to know that now. A one-page note covering spend authority, hiring and exits below executive level, supplier and contract sign-off, and who chairs which operating meetings is enough. It does not need to be a legal document; it needs to exist.
Ask what the board thinks the problem is. If you can, speak to the Chair separately. Boards and chief executives sometimes have different accounts of why the role exists, and the gap between them is usually where the difficulty lies. One may see the COO as the person who frees the CEO to focus on growth and investors; the other may see the role as a hedge, or as succession. Both are legitimate, but you need to know which one you have been hired for.
Agree what success at day ninety looks like. Not targets — it is too early for those — but a shared understanding of what you will have produced: a diagnosis, a view on the team, a plan for the following year and at least one thing finished. Writing this down protects you from a board that later remembers having expected more.
Also establish whether you will be appointed as a statutory director. If so you carry duties including the obligation under section 172 of the Companies Act 2006 to promote the success of the company, together with personal exposure — and directors’ and officers’ cover should reflect it. It is reasonable to ask to see the policy before you join. If the role scope is still loose, our COO job description is a useful checklist for what the responsibilities usually cover and where they tend to overlap with the CEO, CFO and commercial leadership.
The 90-day plan at a glance: days 1–30, 31–60 and 61–90
The detail follows below, but the shape of a sound COO transition is simple. Each phase has a different job, and most problems come from doing the third phase’s work in the first.
| Phase | Main job | What you should have by the end |
|---|---|---|
| Days 1–30 | Listen, read, count and watch the business run | A stakeholder map, an audit of the operating basics and a written list of what strikes you as odd |
| Days 31–60 | Form a private view and test it with a small number of people | Answers to the four questions on the constraint, the team, what should stop and what the board does not know |
| Days 61–90 | Finish one visible change and present your diagnosis | A completed quick win, a first board paper and a sequenced plan for the structural work |
Treat the boundaries loosely. A business in difficulty may need you to act in week two; a stable one may give you longer. What matters is the order: understand, then decide, then act — and be seen to finish something before you ask the organisation to trust you with something larger. Our wider guide to executive onboarding in the first 90 days covers the employer’s side of the same process.
Weeks one to three: listen and count
Resist the pressure to announce anything. New COOs are frequently expected to arrive with a plan, and arriving with one before you understand the business is how you end up defending a position you no longer believe.
Meet two levels down, not one. Your direct reports will tell you what they want you to know. The layer beneath them will tell you what is actually happening. Book those conversations yourself rather than having them arranged. Ask the same three questions of everyone — what should we stop doing, what slows you down most, and what would you change if you were me — and write the answers down the same day.
Read twelve months of board packs and management accounts. You are looking for what the board has been told repeatedly and what has not changed as a result. Recurring items are usually unresolved problems that have become furniture.
Establish where the cash goes. Not the budget — the cash. Cost to serve by customer or product line, if anyone has it. If nobody has it, that absence is itself one of your findings and often the most valuable one.
Watch one full cycle of something. A month end, a production run, an order from enquiry to delivery. Following one process end to end reveals more than a fortnight of meetings about processes.
Keep a list of what strikes you as odd. Outside eyes have a short shelf life. Within two months the workarounds, duplicated reports and unexplained approvals will start to seem normal and you will stop seeing them. Write them down in the first fortnight, even if you do nothing with the list until later.
What to audit in the first 30 days
An audit in this sense is not a formal review. It is a structured look at the basics, so that you know which of them you can rely on. The areas worth covering in most businesses are:
- Management information. Which numbers the business runs on, who produces them, how long they take and whether anyone trusts them. Unreliable MI is the most common inherited problem and the one that undermines every other decision.
- The operating rhythm. Which meetings exist, who attends, what they decide and which ones nobody would miss.
- Customer service and delivery. Complaints, returns, late orders and service-level performance — and whether these are measured at all.
- Key contracts and suppliers. Renewal dates, single points of failure, and any agreements nobody can find.
- Systems and data. What is held where, which spreadsheets the business secretly depends on, and which implementations are half finished.
- People and structure. Spans of control, vacancies, recent leavers, and who the organisation actually goes to when something breaks.
- Risk, health and safety and compliance. Open actions from audits or inspections, insurance renewals and any regulatory commitments with deadlines.
Building a stakeholder map
By the end of the first month you should be able to draw, on one page, the people whose support you need and where each of them stands. A simple grid works: influence over your agenda on one axis, current attitude to the role on the other. The usual names on it are the CEO, the Chair and any investor director, the CFO, the commercial or sales lead, your own direct reports, the informal leaders two levels down, and the two or three customers or suppliers who matter most.
Pay particular attention to the CFO. In many businesses the COO and CFO share ownership of cost, systems and reporting, and a poor relationship between them is visible to everyone within weeks. Agree early who owns what, especially where the finance function sits inside or alongside operations. Pay attention too to anyone who applied for the COO role internally, or who was doing parts of it before you arrived. They will either become your most useful ally or your most persistent obstacle, and the difference often depends on how they were treated in your first fortnight.
Appointing a Chief Operating Officer?
Exec Capital helps boards define what the first ninety days should achieve before the search begins, then puts forward operators who have made the transition before — permanent, interim or fractional.
Weeks four to eight: form a view and test it
By week eight you should hold a private answer to four questions.
| Question | What you are looking for |
|---|---|
| Where is the constraint? | The single thing limiting growth or margin — not a list |
| Who can make the step? | An honest assessment of each senior manager against where the business is going |
| What should stop? | Products, reports, meetings or customers that cost more than they return |
| What does the board not know? | The gap between the reported position and the real one |
Test the view with the CEO and with one person outside the leadership team whose judgement you have come to trust. Testing it widely at this stage invites negotiation before you have authority to hold a line.
This is also the point to check your own assumptions. If your diagnosis looks remarkably like the problems at your last employer, be suspicious of it. Go back to the data and to the people two levels down and ask whether the pattern is really here, or whether you have brought it with you.
Writing your first board paper
Somewhere around day sixty to ninety, most new COOs present to the board for the first time in their own right. It is worth more preparation than it usually gets, because it is the board’s first direct evidence of how you think.
A good first paper is short — three or four pages plus appendices — and does four things. It states what you found, including the uncomfortable parts, in plain language. It names the constraint and explains why you think it is the constraint rather than one problem among many. It sets out what you propose to do in the next six to twelve months, in sequence, with what each step depends on. And it says clearly what you need from the board: a decision, an investment, patience, or support for a difficult people change.
Agree the content with the CEO before it goes out. A board that hears the COO and CEO describe the business differently will spend the meeting on the disagreement rather than on the plan. Equally, do not let the paper be edited into something bland. If the board does not know something important, the first paper is the moment to tell them, before the problem becomes yours.
Avoid the temptation to fill the paper with activity — meetings held, sites visited, people met. The board will assume you have done that. What it wants is judgement.
Weeks nine to twelve: finish one thing
Credibility in an operational role is built on completion, not on analysis. Choose one change that is meaningful, achievable inside the window and unambiguous when it is done — and finish it.
Good candidates: removing a report nobody uses, fixing a handover that everyone complains about, closing an overdue process, or resolving a supplier or contract issue that has been drifting. Bad candidates: anything requiring a system implementation, anything dependent on another function’s cooperation, and anything that cannot be declared complete.
The point is not the value of the change. It is that the organisation sees you close something out. Everything harder becomes possible afterwards.
Quick wins versus structural fixes
Most new COOs find two kinds of problem, and the mistake is to treat them the same way. Quick wins are local, low-risk and within your own authority. Structural fixes change how the business is organised, what it spends or what systems it runs on, and they need the board, the CEO and usually the CFO with you.
| Quick win | Structural fix | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical examples | Cutting a redundant report, fixing an approval bottleneck, clearing a backlog | Operating model redesign, ERP replacement, site consolidation, leadership changes |
| Who decides | You | CEO and board, often with investors |
| When | Inside the first 90 days | Diagnosed in the first 90 days, delivered over the following year or more |
| Main risk | Choosing something too trivial to register | Starting before you understand the business or have the authority to finish |
The right sequence is to deliver one or two quick wins while diagnosing the structural problems, then use the credibility the quick wins earn to make the case for the structural work in your first board paper. Reversing the order — launching a structural programme in month two — is one of the most reliable ways to lose the senior team.
The people question
Almost every incoming COO inherits at least one senior manager who is not equal to where the business is going. How this is handled shapes the whole tenure.
Reach a view within ninety days, but act deliberately rather than quickly. Moving someone in week four, before you have earned the right, reads as arbitrary and frightens the people you want to keep. Waiting a year is worse — the organisation concludes you cannot see what everyone else can, and your authority erodes quietly.
Separate the role from the person. Sometimes the manager is capable but in the wrong seat, and a change of scope solves the problem. Sometimes the role itself is wrongly defined — a common example is the gap between an operations director and a head of operations, which our guide to operations director vs head of operations explains. Be clear which problem you are solving before you act.
Where a change is needed, take proper advice on process before starting the conversation. Fair procedure matters both legally and reputationally, and guidance on handling it correctly is published by Acas. A well-handled exit is watched closely by everyone remaining.
The COO in a regulated firm: SMF24 and handover
If you are joining an FCA-authorised firm, the first ninety days carry an extra layer. In firms within the enhanced tier of the Senior Managers and Certification Regime, and in PRA-regulated banks and insurers, the person responsible for internal operations and technology typically holds the chief operations function (SMF24). In smaller, core-tier firms, a COO who sits on the board will often be approved as an executive director instead, and one who does not may fall outside the senior manager regime altogether. Confirm which applies before you start, because it changes what you are personally accountable for.
Three things deserve attention early. First, your Statement of Responsibilities: read it before you accept, make sure it matches what you have actually been hired to do, and raise anything that gives you accountability without authority. Second, the handover. The FCA’s rules on handover procedures and material (SYSC 25.9) expect firms to take reasonable steps to give an incoming senior manager the information they need to do the job. Ask for the handover pack, open issues, regulatory correspondence and any outstanding remediation in week one, and if there is no pack, record that you asked. Third, approval timing. If your approval is still pending when you start, be clear with the firm about what you may and may not do until it comes through.
The regime is changing. The FCA’s policy statement PS26/6 brought in the first phase of SMCR reforms in April 2026, and HM Treasury has confirmed it intends to legislate for further changes, including reducing the number of roles needing pre-approval and moving detail on Statements of Responsibilities into regulators’ rules. Check the current position with the firm’s compliance function when you join rather than relying on how the process worked at a previous employer. Our SMF24 hiring guide covers the role in more depth.
Interim and fractional COOs: a compressed 90 days
An interim COO is usually brought in because something needs doing now — a stabilisation, a gap after a departure, or a specific programme. The listening phase still matters, but it shrinks to days rather than weeks, and the mandate should be defined tightly at the outset: what the interim is there to deliver, by when, and what “done” looks like. The best interims produce a short written diagnosis by the end of week two and agree it with the CEO, so that everyone knows what the remaining time is for.
A fractional or part-time COO faces the opposite problem: the same ninety calendar days, but perhaps a fifth of the time in the building. That makes the stakeholder map and the operating rhythm more important, not less. Fix which days you are present, which meetings you own, and who acts for you in between. Choose a quick win that can progress while you are away. And be explicit with the team about how to reach you, or problems will route back to the CEO by default and the role will quietly fail.
In both cases, plan the exit from the start. An interim or fractional COO who leaves behind a documented operating rhythm and a capable deputy has done the job; one who leaves behind dependency has not.
Four ways the first 90 days go wrong
Arriving with the last company’s playbook. What worked elsewhere may not translate, and the team will detect an imported solution immediately. Experience should shape the questions you ask, not dictate the answers.
Becoming the escalation point. If every unresolved problem routes to you by week six, the role stops being strategic. Build the mechanism that resolves issues without you and then defend it. A weekly operating review with clear owners and a short action log does more than any amount of personal firefighting.
Announcing a transformation. Large change programmes declared in the first quarter usually reflect an incomplete understanding of the business. Start smaller and earn the right to the larger argument.
Neglecting the board. The board sees the CEO monthly and the COO occasionally. Executives who never build direct board relationships find they have no advocate when a difficult decision needs backing. Ask the CEO for regular, agreed contact with the Chair, and use your first board paper to show the board how you think. The Institute of Directors publishes useful material for those new to board-level exposure.
Behind all four sits the problem described in the first section: a chief executive who said they wanted to step back from operations and then kept intervening, and a COO who did not raise it until month nine, by which point the senior team had already worked out whose instructions actually counted. Raise it in week two, privately and specifically.
A 90-day checklist for a new COO
A short list to work through, and to revisit at day thirty, sixty and ninety:
- Decision rights agreed with the CEO and written down
- Separate conversation held with the Chair about why the role exists
- Day-ninety outputs agreed: diagnosis, team view, plan and one finished change
- Director status, duties and D&O cover confirmed
- Regulated firms: SMF status, Statement of Responsibilities and handover material reviewed
- Meetings held with direct reports and the layer below them
- Twelve months of board packs and management accounts read
- Cash and cost to serve understood, or the gap recorded as a finding
- One end-to-end process observed in full
- List of what strikes you as odd kept from the first fortnight
- Stakeholder map drawn and CFO responsibilities agreed
- Private answers to the four questions, tested with the CEO
- A view formed on each senior manager, with advice taken before any change
- One quick win completed and visibly closed
- First board paper delivered with a sequenced structural plan
What boards and CEOs can do to help
Most of this guide is written for the incoming COO, but the transition is a shared responsibility. The businesses whose COO appointments hold tend to do a few things consistently. They agree the purpose of the role before they start the search, rather than letting each candidate interview shape it. They tell the senior team, before the new COO arrives, which decisions are moving to them. The CEO stops attending the meetings the COO now owns, and resists the urge to take back problems that are brought to them directly. And the board gives the new COO a direct line to the Chair and a slot on the agenda by the end of the first quarter.
Getting the hire itself right matters most of all. A COO appointed into a vague role, or one whose real purpose differs from the one described at interview, starts the ninety days at a disadvantage no plan can fully recover. Exec Capital’s COO search work starts with that definition, so the person appointed and the board appointing them begin with the same understanding of the job.
Frequently asked questions
What should a new COO do in the first 90 days?
Spend the first month listening, auditing the basics and establishing where the cash goes; the second forming and testing a private view of the constraint and the team; and the third completing one visible change and presenting a diagnosis to the board. Settle decision rights with the CEO before starting.
What should be in a COO 90-day plan?
A listening schedule covering two levels down, a review of twelve months of board papers and management accounts, an assessment of cost to serve, a stakeholder map, a private view on the senior team, one completed early win and a first board paper. Avoid committing to a transformation programme within the window.
How long does it take a new COO to have an impact?
Visible impact usually lands between months three and six. Structural change — operating model, team composition, cost base — typically takes considerably longer, often a year or more. Boards expecting measurable improvement inside a quarter are generally expecting the wrong thing.
Should a new COO restructure the team immediately?
No. Form a view within ninety days but act deliberately. Restructuring before understanding the business risks removing capability you cannot see, and moves made too early read as arbitrary to the people you want to retain.
Does a COO need FCA approval?
It depends on the firm. In enhanced-tier SMCR firms and PRA-regulated banks and insurers the COO usually holds SMF24 and needs approval before performing the role. In core-tier firms a board-level COO is often approved as an executive director. The SMCR is being reformed, so confirm the current requirements with the firm.
What is the biggest mistake new COOs make?
Not resolving decision rights with the chief executive at the outset. Where the CEO says they will step back from operations but continues to intervene, the COO’s authority is undermined in front of the team — and the longer it goes unaddressed, the harder it becomes to raise.
Appointing a COO who will hold?
Exec Capital places permanent, interim and fractional Chief Operating Officers across the UK, starting with a clear definition of what the role must achieve in its first year.
Related COO and Operations Search Services
Exec Capital places operational leaders on permanent, interim and fractional terms across the UK. Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.
PRACTICE AREA
COO Search
Permanent Chief Operating Officer appointments for scaling, multi-site, family-owned and investor-backed businesses.
→ Family Office COO Recruitment
PRACTICE AREA
Interim & Fractional COO
Operational leadership for a gap, a stabilisation or a business that needs senior judgement a few days a week.
PRACTICE AREA
Regulated & PE-Backed
COOs for FCA-authorised firms and private equity portfolio companies, where accountability and pace both matter.
→ Private Equity Executive Search
PRACTICE AREA
Operations Leadership
Operations directors, permanent and interim, where the requirement sits just below the C-suite.
→ Operations Director Recruitment
Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.
About the author
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name, with more than 25 years’ experience operating at C-suite level. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what senior leadership hires actually require. View Adrian’s ICAEW profile.
Related posts:
The Cost of a Bad COO Hire: How Specialist Executive Search Firms Mitigate Risks
Top Traits to Look for in a Fractional COO Candidate
Top Qualities to Look for When Hiring a COO: Executive Recruiters Share Their Insights
How Fractional COOs Help Navigate Rapid Operational Change
Operational Pivot? Bring in a Fractional COO
Part-time UK-based COO for European operations
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant and holds an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name with over 25 years’ experience operating at C-suite level, Adrian brings direct executive experience to senior search. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies, and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what leadership hires actually require.