Consumer Duty is the most significant shift in the FCA’s regulatory philosophy in a generation. The move from rules-based compliance to an outcomes-focused standard — where firms must show that retail customers are consistently receiving good outcomes — has changed what is expected of boards and senior management in ways that are still being absorbed. One of the clearest practical consequences is that it has changed who regulated firms need to hire, and what those individuals need to be able to demonstrate.
This guide is written for boards, Nomination Committees and investors at FCA-regulated firms who are asking whether their current leadership team has the competence Consumer Duty requires — and what to do if it does not. It covers the board’s accountability, what Consumer Duty literacy looks like in a director or executive, how each of the four outcomes translates into a hiring brief, and how the FCA’s recent changes to the Duty and to the Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) affect appointment decisions in late 2026.
The short version: the Duty has not become lighter. The FCA has trimmed some of the scaffolding around it, but the obligation on the governing body to understand, challenge and evidence customer outcomes is unchanged. That makes the people on the board, and the senior executives who report to it, the main control a firm has.
The Board’s Direct Accountability Under Consumer Duty
The FCA has been explicit that Consumer Duty is a board-level responsibility, not something that can be handed to the compliance function. Under PRIN 2A.8, a firm must prepare a report on the outcomes its customers are receiving at least once a year, and its board or equivalent governing body must review and approve it. In doing so the board confirms whether the firm is complying with the Duty, considers whether its future business strategy is consistent with the Duty, and agrees any action needed. Every director — executive and non-executive — is therefore part of a formal confirmation that the firm is delivering good outcomes for retail customers. Our guide to the Consumer Duty annual board report covers the mechanics in more detail.
That is a material commitment, and boards that approve a management-produced document without genuinely scrutinising it are exposed if the FCA’s supervisory view subsequently differs. The FCA’s own review of the first round of board reports, covering 180 firms, warned that the board should not act as a “rubber stamp” and noted that it was often not clear from the reports or minutes that effective challenge had taken place (FCA: Consumer Duty board reports — good practice and areas for improvement).
This accountability structure has made Consumer Duty literacy a board-level competence requirement. A board without directors who can challenge management’s Consumer Duty assertions — interrogate the data, question the methodology and identify gaps in the evidence of good outcomes — is structurally weak in a way that creates regulatory and governance risk. Recognising that gap and closing it through the next appointment is the most direct lever the chair has, which is why the chair’s role in Consumer Duty oversight and the Nomination Committee’s work are so closely linked.
The FCA also expects the board to be engaged in Consumer Duty oversight throughout the year, not only when the annual report is approved. Board minutes, management information packs and committee papers are all potential evidence of whether the board is providing genuine oversight. Appointment decisions should take account of whether incoming directors will be able to engage meaningfully with the routine Consumer Duty MI the firm produces, from the first board meeting they attend.
What Has Changed Since the Duty Came Into Force
Boards planning appointments in late 2026 are doing so against a moving backdrop. Several changes are relevant to how a board is composed and how senior roles are specified, and it is important to separate what is in force from what is still proposed.
The board champion is now optional
The FCA’s original guidance expected firms to appoint a Consumer Duty champion at board level, usually a non-executive director. On 27 February 2025 the FCA announced that boards could decide for themselves whether to keep the role (FCA speech: The Gordian knot of growth). Many firms have kept a champion because it works for them. Others have dropped the title and spread the responsibility across the board and its committees. Either approach is acceptable, but the second places more weight on the Consumer Duty capability of the whole board — there is no longer a single named director whose job it is to hold the subject. If your board has removed the champion role, the skills matrix needs to show where that capability now sits.
Consultation on the scope of the Duty
In June 2026 the FCA published CP26/23, a consultation on the scope and proportionality of the Duty (FCA CP26/23: Consumer Duty scope and proportionality). Its proposals include removing business with non-UK customers from scope, making it clearer where the Duty applies, clarifying how firms in distribution chains can rely on each other, and explaining how the Duty interacts with other product governance rules. The consultation closed in September 2026 and the FCA has said it expects to publish a policy statement and final rules in the first quarter of 2027. These are proposals until the final rules appear. For hiring purposes, the likely effect is to sharpen rather than remove obligations for firms that deal directly with UK retail customers — and to make it more important that firms in wholesale or intermediary positions understand exactly where their responsibilities start and stop.
Changes to the Senior Managers and Certification Regime
Most of the FCA’s first phase of SM&CR reforms took effect on 24 April 2026 under PS26/6, covering areas including the 12-week rule, statements of responsibilities, regulatory references and the thresholds for enhanced firms (FCA PS26/6: SM&CR review). The Financial Services and Markets Bill, introduced in Parliament in May 2026, proposes repealing the statutory Certification Regime and moving more of the detail into regulators’ rules. In October 2026 the FCA followed with a phase 2 consultation, CP26/37, which proposes removing the Certification Regime, removing certain senior management functions, streamlining SMF applications and ending ongoing submissions of statements of responsibilities (FCA CP26/37: SM&CR review phase 2). The consultation runs to January 2027, with final rules expected in the first half of 2027.
None of this reduces individual accountability for Consumer Duty outcomes. Senior managers remain accountable for their areas, and the Conduct Rules still apply. What it may change is the administrative burden around approval and certification — which, if the proposals go through, could make it quicker to bring senior people in, but will not lower the bar on whether they are the right people.
Hiring a compliance leader or NED with Consumer Duty depth?
Exec Capital finds compliance, risk and board candidates for FCA-regulated firms and assesses each one against the Consumer Duty outcomes their role touches.
What Consumer Duty Literacy Means in Practice
Consumer Duty literacy at board level is not the same as technical regulatory knowledge. Directors are not expected to know the detail of every FCA policy statement. They are expected to apply sound judgement to whether the firm’s products, services, pricing and communications are genuinely serving retail customers well — and to escalate concerns when the evidence suggests they are not.
Candidates who have worked in consumer-facing financial services — retail banking, wealth management, insurance, consumer credit — and who have been involved in product design, pricing decisions or customer experience governance are usually better placed to provide this judgement than those who have worked only in wholesale or institutional settings. Boards dominated by people from institutional backgrounds may have a structural gap in Consumer Duty oversight that appointment decisions should address.
The practical test is whether a director, reading a management pack that shows high customer satisfaction scores and low complaint volumes, would ask the right follow-up questions: how the satisfaction survey was designed and who answered it; whether complaints data captures every form of poor outcome, including customers who simply leave; and whether the groups with the lowest scores are the ones most at risk of harm. Directors who accept headline metrics without probing how they were built are not providing the oversight the Duty requires.
In an interview, that literacy tends to show up in a few recognisable ways:
- Specific examples. The candidate can describe a decision they influenced because of outcomes data — a product withdrawn, a fee changed, a process redesigned — rather than talking about frameworks in the abstract.
- Comfort with imperfect data. They understand that outcomes MI is rarely complete, and can explain how they would form a view when the data is partial or contradictory.
- Attention to vulnerable customers. They ask how the firm identifies customers with characteristics of vulnerability and whether those customers get outcomes as good as everyone else’s.
- Willingness to disagree. They can point to a time they challenged a commercial proposal on customer grounds and what happened next.
The Four Outcome Areas and Their Hiring Implications
Products and services. Firms must ensure their products and services are designed to meet the needs of identified groups of retail customers and are distributed through channels appropriate to those groups. This requires executives and NEDs who understand product design from the customer’s perspective — not only from a commercial or risk perspective. Heads of product, distribution directors and chief customer officers with a genuine record of customer-centred design are in demand, and chief customer officer recruitment at regulated firms now routinely includes Consumer Duty as part of the brief. The key hiring question is whether the candidate has actually changed a product or distribution channel as a result of an outcomes assessment, or whether their Consumer Duty work has stayed at policy level.
Price and value. Firms must show that the total price customers pay is reasonable relative to the overall benefits of the product or service. This is a demanding standard that requires genuine analytical work — not simply confirming that prices are in line with the market. CFOs, pricing directors and strategy executives who know how to build and defend a fair value assessment are increasingly valued. Explaining to the FCA why a product that looks expensive relative to its features nonetheless represents fair value — in terms of service quality, risk management, ongoing support or the outcomes it delivers — requires a level of analytical and commercial sophistication that is not universal.
Consumer understanding. Firms must ensure their communications equip retail customers to make informed decisions at each stage of the product lifecycle. This raises the importance of clear communication across the senior team and makes it a relevant assessment criterion in more hiring decisions than before. Marketing directors, digital product heads and customer experience executives are the most directly affected, but the standard also applies to the quality of information the board itself receives and relies on. A board pack that cannot be understood by the people approving it is a consumer understanding problem in miniature.
Consumer support. Firms must provide support that meets customers’ needs throughout the product lifecycle — particularly when customers are in difficulty, want to cancel or switch, or are trying to understand their options. This has particular implications for operational and technology leadership. The systems, processes and people that deliver support need to be adequate, and the executive responsible for them needs to understand what adequate looks like under the Duty — not just call answering times, but the quality of the outcomes the support function actually produces. A COO or operations director who designs exit processes to be as frictionless as entry processes is demonstrating Consumer Duty thinking without needing to use the phrase.
Gaps That Appointment Decisions Should Address
Boards reviewing their composition in light of Consumer Duty should consider three questions:
- Consumer-facing experience. Does the board have at least one director with direct experience of consumer-facing financial services, ideally in a product, distribution or customer experience role?
- Quantitative challenge. Is there a director with the analytical capability to scrutinise fair value analysis rather than accept management’s conclusions?
- The right information. Is the board receiving MI broken down by customer segment, product and channel, so it can form a genuine view of outcomes — including for customers with characteristics of vulnerability?
Where the answer to any of these is no, the next NED appointment should be shaped to address the gap. That may mean departing from the profile that would otherwise have been the natural next hire. A board that is strong on credit risk and capital markets may need to prioritise consumer-facing experience over more financial markets expertise, even if that is less familiar territory. Specialist financial services non-executive recruitment starts with this kind of gap analysis rather than a generic NED profile.
The board skills matrix should be reviewed against Consumer Duty specifically, not just against general financial services governance criteria. Many firms have refreshed their skills matrix in recent years without updating it for the competences the Duty requires. A matrix that does not include Consumer Duty capability as an explicit category is not giving the Nomination Committee what it needs to prioritise appointments correctly — and, where the board champion role has been dropped, it is the main place that capability is now recorded.
Committee structure matters too. Some firms route Consumer Duty oversight through the risk committee, some through audit, and some have set up a dedicated customer or conduct committee. Whichever model you use, the chair of that committee needs the depth to lead the discussion, and the committee needs at least one member who has worked close to retail customers.
Executive Hiring Decisions
At executive level, Consumer Duty has most visibly changed the brief for CEOs, chief customer officers, compliance directors and heads of distribution. In each case boards are looking for people who can demonstrate not just familiarity with the regulation but a working understanding of what good outcomes look like in practice — and a record of decisions that produced them.
The compliance function has been affected most directly. The Compliance Director or Chief Compliance Officer at a regulated firm now needs Consumer Duty expertise as a core competence, not an adjacent area of knowledge. Firms where compliance has historically focused on conduct of business rules and MiFID requirements may find that existing senior compliance staff need development support — or that the next senior hire needs to be profiled specifically for Consumer Duty depth. When we run compliance and risk recruitment for regulated firms, the ability to interpret ambiguous outcomes data, spot emerging risks before they become regulatory issues, and tell the board plainly where the firm is exposed to FCA challenge are the capabilities that separate a strong shortlist from a long one.
For many firms the senior compliance role is also an approved one. Where the Head of Compliance holds SMF16, the appointment carries the FCA approval process with it, and the candidate’s Consumer Duty record will be part of how the firm justifies the appointment. Our SMF16 Head of Compliance recruitment work builds that evidence into the search from the start rather than leaving it to the application stage.
Risk leadership is affected in a similar way. A chief risk officer whose framework treats conduct risk as a footnote to prudential risk will struggle to give the board a joined-up view of customer harm. Boards should ask how a risk candidate has built customer outcomes into risk appetite, key risk indicators and the second-line challenge of the first line.
Covering the Gap While You Hire
A permanent senior compliance or risk appointment at a regulated firm takes time — the search itself, notice periods that are often long at this level, and, where the role is an SMF, regulatory approval. A board report cycle or a supervisory request will not wait for that process to finish.
Interim leadership is the usual answer. An interim chief compliance officer can take ownership of the Consumer Duty programme, prepare the board for the annual report and handle supervisory contact while the permanent search runs. For smaller firms that do not need a full-time senior compliance leader, a fractional arrangement can provide the same depth for one or two days a week. The point is to avoid a period where nobody senior owns the evidence of good outcomes.
Where the interim role carries a senior management function, the firm should plan for approval as early as possible. The 12-week rule allows temporary cover in some circumstances, and it was one of the areas updated under PS26/6, so check the current position before relying on it.
The FCA’s Multi-Firm Review Findings
The FCA has published findings from multi-firm reviews of Consumer Duty implementation that show where firms are falling short and, by implication, what competences boards and senior management need to develop. Common themes include boards receiving high-level assurance that the Duty is being met without supporting evidence of good outcomes; fair value assessments that are more descriptive than analytical; and customer support processes designed around the firm’s operational convenience rather than the customer’s needs.
The FCA’s review of board reports added detail. Stronger reports combined quantitative and qualitative data, linked complaint trends to root causes and were open about where poor outcomes existed. Weaker reports relied on generic statements that products suited their target market, contained data that did not support their conclusions, and set out action plans without owners, timescales or evidence that the actions had worked.
Each of these findings has a direct hiring implication. Where a firm’s own Consumer Duty review has identified any of these gaps, the board should consider whether the current executive team has the competence to close them — or whether appointments need to bring in people with specific expertise where the firm is most vulnerable. A data and MI gap, for example, often points to a need for stronger analytical capability in the first line rather than more compliance resource.
Consumer Duty and Remuneration Design
Consumer Duty has also influenced how regulated firms design remuneration, particularly at senior level. The FCA has made clear it expects remuneration and incentive arrangements to support — not undermine — good outcomes for retail customers. Where executive pay is tied mainly to revenue growth or new business volumes, with no reference to customer outcomes, the FCA may question whether the incentive structure is consistent with the Duty.
This has implications for hiring. Executives considering a move to a regulated firm will look closely at the remuneration structure, and candidates with strong Consumer Duty credentials may be uncomfortable accepting packages that tie variable pay entirely to financial metrics. Boards designing packages for senior appointments should consider whether the incentive structure sends the right signal about the firm’s commitment to the Duty — and the remuneration committee should be able to explain how outcome measures feed into variable pay.
In practice, that usually means a balanced scorecard with customer outcome measures given real weight, malus and clawback provisions that can be triggered by conduct failings, and a clear link between the board report’s findings and the remuneration committee’s decisions.
Supervisory Risk and the Quality of the Senior Team
The FCA has used its supervisory tools actively since Consumer Duty came into force: multi-firm reviews, targeted data requests and firm-specific visits. Firms that face supervisory engagement on Consumer Duty quickly find that the quality of the board’s and senior management’s engagement with the regulator matters as much as the substance of the firm’s position.
Directors who can engage credibly with FCA supervisors — who understand the framework, can set out the firm’s position clearly, and can acknowledge weaknesses without alarming the regulator unnecessarily — tend to manage supervisory relationships more effectively. This is not a trivial skill and it should be assessed when relevant appointments arise. Candidates who have represented a firm in FCA supervisory meetings, or who have helped prepare responses to FCA data requests on Consumer Duty, bring something that cannot be learned from a briefing pack.
The same applies to the chair. A chair who has led a board through a supervisory review, a skilled person review or a remediation programme understands how the board’s own records will be read. That experience is worth weighting heavily when a regulated firm is choosing its next chair.
Working with Exec Capital
Exec Capital works with FCA-regulated firms across retail banking, wealth management, insurance, consumer credit and investment services to place executives and non-executive directors with the competence Consumer Duty requires. We assess candidates against the outcome areas relevant to each role and help boards and Nomination Committees shape the brief so it attracts the right profile. Our candidate assessments address Consumer Duty competence specifically, rather than treating it as general regulatory awareness.
Whether you need a permanent compliance director, an interim lead to carry the next board report, or a non-executive who can challenge management on fair value, our compliance and risk recruitment team and wider board practice can help. Searches are run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.
Frequently asked questions
Does Consumer Duty require a specific board member?
No. The FCA originally expected a board-level Consumer Duty champion, but since February 2025 firms can decide for themselves whether to have one. The board as a whole remains responsible for reviewing and approving the annual Consumer Duty report and for overseeing customer outcomes through the year.
Should the next NED appointment be a Consumer Duty specialist?
Not necessarily a specialist, but if the board lacks directors with consumer-facing financial services experience or the analytical ability to challenge fair value work, the next appointment should be shaped to fill that gap. A skills matrix review against the four outcomes is the best way to decide.
What does the annual board report require?
Under PRIN 2A.8, the firm must report at least annually on the outcomes its customers are receiving. The board must review and approve the report, confirm whether the firm is complying with the Duty, consider whether its strategy is consistent with it, and agree any actions needed.
Will CP26/23 reduce what boards have to do?
CP26/23 is a consultation, and final rules are expected in early 2027. Its proposals focus on scope and proportionality — for example non-UK customers and distribution chains — rather than removing the board’s core obligations for firms serving UK retail customers.
How do the SM&CR changes affect senior hiring?
Phase 1 changes under PS26/6 took effect on 24 April 2026. The Financial Services and Markets Bill and the FCA’s phase 2 consultation propose removing the Certification Regime and streamlining SMF applications. If adopted, these could reduce administration around appointments, but senior managers remain individually accountable for their areas, including customer outcomes.
Can an interim compliance lead prepare the board report?
Yes. Many firms use an interim chief compliance officer to run the Consumer Duty programme and prepare the board for the annual report while a permanent appointment is made. The board still owns the report and must approve it.
Does your board have the Consumer Duty capability it needs?
Whether the gap is a non-executive, a compliance director or interim cover for the next board report, we can help you define the brief and find the right person.
Related Regulated-Firm Search Services
Exec Capital places compliance, risk, executive and board leaders at FCA-regulated firms on permanent, interim and fractional terms. Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.
PRACTICE AREA
Compliance & Risk
Compliance directors, heads of compliance and risk leaders with the depth to evidence good customer outcomes.
→ Compliance and Risk Recruitment
→ Head of Compliance Recruitment
PRACTICE AREA
Board & Non-Executive
Non-executive directors and chairs who can challenge management on outcomes, fair value and customer data.
→ Financial Services NED Recruitment
→ Chair of FCA-Regulated Firm Recruitment
PRACTICE AREA
Interim Regulatory Cover
Senior compliance leadership to own the Consumer Duty programme while a permanent hire is made.
PRACTICE AREA
Regulated Leadership
CEOs and customer-facing executives for firms where customer outcomes sit at the centre of the brief.
→ CEO of FCA-Regulated Firm Recruitment
→ Chief Customer Officer Recruitment
Every search is run by our specialist team, with Adrian Lawrence FCA overseeing each mandate.
About the author
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant holding an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name, with more than 25 years’ experience operating at C-suite level. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what senior leadership hires actually require. View Adrian’s ICAEW profile.
Related posts:
Senior Independent Director (SMF14) Recruitment at FCA Firms
Hiring a CEO Without Previous SMF Approval
How long does FCA SMF approval actually take? A realistic timeline for regulated firm boards
Permanent, Interim or Fractional: Which Compliance Hire Does Your Firm Actually Need?
Chair Succession in PE-Backed Regulated Firms
Chair of Risk Committee (SMF10) Appointments at FCA Firms
Adrian Lawrence FCA is the founder of Exec Capital. He is a Chartered Accountant and holds an ICAEW practising certificate in his own name with over 25 years’ experience operating at C-suite level, Adrian brings direct executive experience to senior search. His background spans private equity-backed businesses, owner-managed companies, and listed environments, giving Exec Capital a practitioner’s understanding of what leadership hires actually require.